“…Reference Simulation content L C SP TP QL QT (Amin & Ikhsan, 2021) Chemical equilibrium C QT (Chang & Linn, 2013) Chemical thermal dynamics L QL QT (Chen, Chang, Lai & Tsai, 2014) Boyle's Law L C SP QL QT (Chien, Tsai, Chen, Chang & Chen, 2015) Boyle's Law L QT (Correia et al, 2019) Behavior of gases at a sub-microscopic level L SP QL QT (Davenport, Rafferty & Yaron, 2018) Solutions (the mole) L QT (Donnelly, O'Reilly & McGarr, 2013) Unspecified C TP QL QT (Gambari, Gbodi, Olakanmi & Abalaka, 2016) Periodicity and chemical equations L SP QL QT (Gambari, Kawu & Falode, 2018) Identification of cations L QT (Hale-Hanes, 2015) Acid-base reactivity L SP QL QT (Homer & Plass, 2014) Kinetic molecular theory and ideal gas law L QT (Karlsson, Ivarsson & Lindstrom, 2013) Gas solubility L SP TP QL (Lamb & Annetta, 2013) Mole, chemical equations and stoichiometry L SP QT (Levy, 2013) States of aggregation and phase change C QL QT (Olakanmi, 2015) Chemical reactions L QL QT (Osman & Lee, 2013) Electrochemistry L QT (Papadimitropoulos, Dalacosta & Pavlatou, 2021) Acids and bases (properties, Arrhenius theory and pH) L QT (Plass, Milne, Homer, Schwartz, Hayward, Jordan et al, 2012) Kinetic molecular theory L C QT (Pratidhina, Pujianto & Sumardi, 2019) Gas laws L QT (Ryoo, Bedell & Swearingen, 2018) Properties of matter and chemical reactions L QT (Smetana & Bell, 2014) Atomic By way of general results (Figure 3), it was found that 87% of the articles include an analysis of the effect that the use of simulations has on the learning of chemical concepts or models. 19% of the works set out to specifically analyze the development of student competences.…”