Improving oligo-conjugated antibody signal in multimodal single-cell analysis

Abstract

Simultaneous measurement of surface proteins and gene expression within single cells offers highresolution snapshots of complex cell populations. These methods rely on staining cells with oligoconjugated antibodies analogous to staining for flow-and mass cytometry. Unlike flow-and mass cytometry, signal from oligo-conjugated antibodies is not hampered by spectral overlap or limited by the number of metal isotopes, making it a highly sensitive and scalable approach. Signal from oligoconjugated antibodies is quantified by counting reads from high-throughput sequencing. Consequently, cost of sequencing is strictly dependent on the signal intensities and background from the pool of antibodies used in analysis. Thus, considering the "cost-of-signal" as well as optimizing "signal-tonoise", makes titration of oligo-conjugated antibody panels more complex and even more important than for flow-and mass cytometry. In this study, we investigated the titration response of a panel of oligo-conjugated antibodies towards four variables: Antibody concentration, staining volume, cell number at staining, and tissue of origin. We find that staining with high antibody concentrations recommended by published protocols and commercial vendors cause unnecessarily high background signal and that concentrations of many antibodies can be drastically reduced without loss of biological information. Reducing staining volume only affects antibodies targeting highly abundant epitopes used at low concentrations and can be counteracted by reducing cell numbers at staining. We find that background signal from empty droplets can account for a major fraction of the total sequencing reads and is primarily derived from antibodies used at high concentrations. Together, this study provides new insight into the titration response and background signal of oligo-conjugated antibodies and offers concrete guidelines on how such panels can be improved.

Absence of Batf3 reveals a new dimension of cell state heterogeneity within conventional dendritic cells

“…Analysis of the median adt value for each cluster revealed that each Total-Seq antibody produced a substantial background read count (Figure 4B). This is in line with observations by others when using high antibody concentrations as recommended in suppliers' protocols (Buus et al, 2021). Comparing the characteristic features of cDC1 (CD8A, CD24, XCR1) against those of cDC2 (CD11B, CD172A, CD4) in this way revealed that the expression of these markers was largely restricted to a single-cell type (Figure 4B).…”

mRNA COVID-19 vaccine elicits potent adaptive immune response without the persistent inflammation seen in SARS-CoV-2 infection

“…To do this, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were multiplexed and processed using 5' droplet-based scRNA-seq technology (10x Genomics). Surface marker phenotypes were detected using an optimized 60 antibody CITE-seq panel (Buus et al, 2020), generating matching transcriptional and surface protein data. In addition, single-cell T cell receptor (TCR) αβ and γδ, as well as B cell receptor (BCR), sequencing was performed for each sample to evaluate antigen receptor repertoires.…”

Superscan: Supervised Single-Cell Annotation

“…Finally, deciding whether a cell is positive or negative for a given marker requires choosing a threshold which often is not clearly evident from the data, given the potentially high level of background noise resulting from imperfect antibody staining. Antibody titrating is resource-intensive and therefore commonly not performed, resulting in lower-than-ideal data quality 37 .…”