“…Research Sector Source Public Sector (Afriyani et al, 2021); (Azman et al, 2023) (Berman, 2018); (Khalida & Safitri, 2018); (Nugroho, 2017); (Panagopoulos et al, 2011); (Rofaida, 2017); (Siswanto et al, 2021). Private Sector (Amelia & Nasution, 2016); (Deif & Van Beek, 2019;(Fachrunnisa et al, 2020); (Kusumawijaya, 2014); (Mihardjo et al, 2021); (Sangka et al, 2019); (Wijaya et al, 2019) (Liu et al, 2022); (Zheng, 2009); (Panagopoulos et al, 2011). Mixed/Non Specified (de Guzman et al, 2011); (Fajar et al, 2018); (Santoso et al, 2020); (Wu et al, 2016) ; (Hidayat et al, 2022); (Kurniawati et al, 2021) (Milani et al, 2021); (Sirojuddin & Sopiah, 2022); (Tuegeh et al, 2021); (Verma & Venkatesan, 2022); (Yuniarto, 2021) Source: Processed from Various Sources Phenomena typically undergo four main stages of development.…”