Improving reading fluency and comprehension in adult ESL learners using bottom-up and top-down vocabulary training

Abstract

The current research examines the effect of two methods of vocabulary training on reading fluency and comprehension of adult English as second language (ESL) tertiary-bound students. The methods used were isolated vocabulary training (bottom-up reading) and vocabulary training in context (topdown reading). The current exploratory and quasi-experimental study examines the effectiveness of these methods in two intact classes using pre-and posttest measures of students' reading fluency and comprehension. The results show that bottom-up training had a negative impact on fluency and comprehension. In contrast, top-down training positively affected fluency but had no impact on comprehension. Further, the results do suggest that fast-paced reading may potentially lead to improved comprehension. These findings have implications for the type of language instruction used in classrooms and, therefore, for teachers of adult ESL learners.

Running Records1 (RR) as ’n leesassesseringstrategie om leesonderrig in Suid-Afrikaanse grondslagfaseklaskamers te ondersteun

“…Leerders wat op die frustrasievlak lees, kan lees as uitdagend en vervelig ervaar. Sodanige leerders lees gewoonlik minder en het swakker leesvaardighede en 'n beperkte woordeskat (Oliver en Young 2016). Die tweede leesvlak is die instruksionele vlak, wat van toepassing is op leerders met 'n akkuraatheidstelling van tussen 90% en 94% (Harmey en Kabuto 2018; D'Agostino e.a.…”

“…2019). Leerders wat op die instruksionele vlak lees, is geneig om meer te lees en het beter leesvaardighede, leesbegrip en woordeskat (Oliver en Young 2016). Die derde vlak is die onafhanklike vlak, wat geld vir leerders met 'n akkuraatheidstelling van 95% of meer (D'Agostino e.a.…”

The effect of non-invasive vagus nerve stimulation on memory recall in reading: A pilot study

“…Currently, several reading comprehension interventions exist, but they are time consuming and not effective for all users, especially those targeted at adults. For example, while a vocabulary-based training improved reading fluency in adults learning English as a second language, it did not improve comprehension [9]. Researchers have also developed a reading comprehension intervention that focuses on strategies during pre-reading, reading, and post-reading to improve comprehension skills in young adults [10].…”

Reflective Teaching Model for Reading Comprehension

“…Interactive teaching helps the teachers improve their students' reading skills, including the ability to relate students' background knowledge and reading text, generate the skills of questioning, summarizing, recognizing, and decoding the information of the text (Anyiendah et al, 2019). It is the hybrid approach of bottom-up and top-down reading strategies (Oliver, 2016) and, it is also an interaction of many sub-processes such as (1)…”