In Cash We Trust?

Abstract

Many individuals have miserable work lives, in which they must toil away at mind-numbing yet exhausting tasks for hours on end, being ordered about by their superiors, perhaps with few guarantees that this source of income will persist for very long. However, this is only half of the story: what is centrally important is that many of those who endure these conditions are denied a fair wage in return for the burdens that they bear. In this article, I reflect on the significance of this fact in order to argue for the evaporation thesis. This thesis holds that individuals' claims to particular employment-related protections from their government disappear as their earnings increase. In the course of defending this position, I explore the moral difference an employee's wage offer makes to the work conditions that we can expect her to accept, including why there are limits to the role that cash can play here.You see, no labor is really menial unless you're not getting adequate wages. People are always talking about menial labor. But if you're getting a good wage … that isn't menial labor. What makes it menial is the income, the wages.

The Future of the Philosophy of Work

“…47 They are typically also the most highly paid jobs, and often sources of high status. 48 Meanwhile, the lowest-paying jobs also score low on accounts of the goods of work, and are often performed by workers with little or no bargaining power. A second strand in the philosophy of work thus asks how to achieve a fair distribution of the valuable parts of good jobs.…”

“Filling the Ranks”: Moral Risk and the Ethics of Military Recruitment

“…Little work evaluates the different means of creating a volunteer military. 3 However, the trend does seem to be shifting (see, e.g.,Gheaus and Herzog 2016;Kandiyali 2023;Parr 2022;Schouten 2016).…”