In It for the Long Haul? Post‐conflict Statebuilding, Peacebuilding, and the Good Governance Agenda in Timor‐leste

Abstract

SUMMARYStatebuilding after conflict often entails liberal peacebuilding measures. The end of the UN mission in post‐conflict Timor‐Leste in December 2012 provides a unique opportunity to investigate statebuilding in practice. The liberal peacebuilding agenda has met with stiff academic resistance—mainly from the critical theorist camp—and is questioned as an appropriate measure of …statebuilding success. We deploy instead the good governance (GG) agenda as a hybrid local‐liberal guide. Drawing on field work, interviews, and secondary documents, we investigate what we see as four key, intertwined and overlapping aspects of GG: state capacity including the establishment of a state bureaucracy, participation and the engagement of civil society, institution building and rule of law, and corruption control and transparency. We note GG provides a useful policy heuristic, while abstract “one‐size‐fits‐all” liberal peacebuilding models, which avoid the complexities of machinery of government issues, the time taken to develop institutions, and historical and contextual environments of countries, are likely to face severe problems. New states may be dependent on external forces to maintain monopoly of violence. The reversibility and uncertainty of statebuilding and the decades‐long commitment needed by international agencies are noted. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

The role of work motivation as a mediator on the influence of education-training and leadership style on employee performance

“…With the end of the UN mission in post-conflict Timor-Leste in December 2012, there have been some opportunities for state development in practice. Progress has varied, from building state bureaucracies and government machinery, democracy and participation, building institutions including the rule of law, and controlling corruption and transparency (Goldfinch & Derouen Jr, 2014). In this era of globalization, modern business primarily are driven by intellectual capital and human capital helps organizations build and maintain competitive advantage (MacDougall & Hurst, 2005).…”

Because coconuts do not grow in Canberra: Complexity theory and capacity development in Solomon Islands Police Force

“…Statebuilding in “fragile” and postconflict settings has been characterised by rationalist, reductionist, linear change models. The theories of change underlying such interventions provide technical and bureaucratic solutions to “underdevelopment” and conflict based on the assumption that the liberal state and good governance—pursued through public sector capacity building and reform—will provide the foundations for economic development and peace (Boege & Curth‐Bibb, ; Goldfinch & DeRouen, ). Such approaches to statebuilding typically focus on the reform and capacity development of “bureaucratic expertise and machinery of government” as well as democratic and rule‐of‐law institutions (including the provision of property rights and corruption watchdogs; Goldfinch & DeRouen, , p. 96).…”