In it Together Yet Worlds Apart? EU–ASEAN Counter-Terrorism Cooperation After the Bali Bombings

Heiduk, Felix

doi:10.1080/07036337.2014.935361

Cited by 22 publications

(5 citation statements)

References 29 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Given that, through the Lisbon Treaty and the ASEAN Charter, both regional organizations gained legal personality granting them the legal capacity and the powers to act in international affairs, EU-ASEAN cooperation in policy fields often associated with so-called non-traditional security also makes for an interesting case study of how the EU conducts inter-regional affairs. This article builds on earlier research, which found that despite numerous declarations and plan of actions, very little policy transfer has actually taken place between the EU and ASEAN (Heiduk 2009(Heiduk , 2014. The earlier research, however, made very little contribution in terms of explaining this observation.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 79%

“…With this in mind, various scholars have taken issue with the implicit assumption, prevailing in much of the literature on the externalization of EU policies (c.f. Heiduk 2014;Heiduk 2009;Kaunert and Léonard 2011;Chevallier-Govers 2012;Joffé 2008), that norm transfer or norm externalization is essentially undertaken by rational agents skimming norms, ideas and policies around the world for the objectively 'best', most successful one to import based on the assumption that they will provide for similar (successful) results in a different place (and often time) (Stone 1999;Dolowitz and Marsh 2000). This has led newer approaches towards a research agenda, which heavily focuses on the inter-subjective constitution of norms, ideas, meanings, and knowledge.…”

Section: Norm Externalization Transfer and Translationmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Externalizing the EU’s Justice and Home Affairs to Southeast Asia: Prospects and Limitations

Heiduk

2016

JCER

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The transnational security dimension ascribed to many phenomena such as terrorism, drug trafficking, pandemics, or people smuggling has led to increased pressures to increase cooperation across national borders to ‘fight’ or ‘manage’ many of the new, transnational security threats. Against this background the EU has sought to promote its own norms and ideas, policy preferences and its own model of regional cooperation and integration in her external affairs. A number of recent studies have examined the growing potency of the EU to actively promote ideas and policy preferences in its neighborhood as well as with the U.S., however, scant attention has been given to EU cooperation with other regional organizations. By closely examining the EU’s cooperation with ASEAN in two policy fields deemed central within JHA – human trafficking and counter terrorism – this paper seeks not only to broaden the empirical basis of scholarship, but additionally seeks to connect the empirical findings with the wider debate on the EU’s ability to externalize its internal security governance. The study finds that despite numerous declarations and plan of actions, very little policy transfer has actually taken place between the EU and ASEAN. It is argued that any attempt to externalize or transfer policy is met by long-standing ideas and norms, policy paradigms and an established specific modus operandi of regional cooperation within ASEAN itself. This will continue to make nigh impossible any externalization of EU policies to Southeast Asia for the foreseeable future.

show abstract

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 79%

Section: Norm Externalization Transfer and Translationmentioning

confidence: 99%

Externalizing the EU’s Justice and Home Affairs to Southeast Asia: Prospects and Limitations

Heiduk

2016

JCER

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…17 Besides the impact of psychological trauma, the bloody incident had an impact on Indonesia's national security in particular 18 and economic, social, and politicalstability in Asia and the European Union. 19 Lewis's study above voices the aspirations of the local Balinese people to the government to restore the image of Bali as a tourism island by considering the recontextualization of policies and agendas that are in line with Bali's current conditions. 20 The immediate effect on Balinese society is the long-term impact on health and well-being after the Bali Bombing 21 , and negative stigma against Muslims in Bali.…”

Section: Resultsmentioning

confidence: 99%

The Meaning of Religious Moderation on the Resilience of Muslim Minority in Balinese Hindus

Tohari

Raya

2021

JCIMS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Abstract: The Bali bombing around two decades ago has caused deep traumatic events in the world, not only psychological, socioeconomic, and multinational effects, but also serious impacts on the relationship between the two religions: Islam and Hindusm. This study documents how Muslims as a minority group in Bali attempted to survive amidst the Hindu majority and how these two ethnic-religious groups maintain harmonious relationship after the Bali Bombing incident. This study uses a case study methods with an interpretive paradigm and qualitative approach, the aim is to shows that social pressure and discrimination has not harm the relationship between the two in that the Muslim and Hindus cooperate in the economic sector and strengthen the relationship with kinship and marriage. This effort is a way for the Muslim-Hindus to rebuild the moderation of unity which was collapsed in Bali.Keywords: Muslim-Hindus, Bali, majority-minority, relations

show abstract

“…Most empirical cases examined by scholars focus on networks connecting the EU with other countries through the European Neighbourhood Policy. Research that looks at different parts of the world, for example Mugyenzi's (2015) application of Lavenex's transgovernmental network model to EU relations with five sub-Saharan African countries, and Heiduk's (2014) analysis of the externalization of EU anti-terrorism practices to ASEAN countries through transgovernmental cooperation, also finds such power asymmetry.…”

Section: Beyond Diffusionmentioning

confidence: 99%

The Structure of Coordination: Transatlantic Policy Networks and the Mobilization of Business and Civil Society

Kourtikakis

Turkina²,

Postnikov³

2020

J of Common Market Studies

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

External policy networks resolve two collective action problems in EU external relations: engaging nonstate actors from the EU and its partner countries in transnational policymaking and converting this engagement to feedback for policymakers. We use formal network analysis to understand the relationship between network structure and collective action by transnational nonstate actors. Our empirical focus is on the Transatlantic Business Council and the Transatlantic Consumer Dialogue networks, which engage business and consumer advocacy organizations in transatlantic economic policymaking. We find that both are highly centralized around EU and US government institutions, with relatively low, but rising, levels of interaction among nonstate organizations. This structure helps increase engagement by giving organizations opportunities to interact with government institutions, learn from their peers, and, for some, to exercise power. It also helps EU and US institutions harness policy feedback, especially from nonstate actors that have frequent interactions with their peers.

show abstract

In it Together Yet Worlds Apart? EU–ASEAN Counter-Terrorism Cooperation After the Bali Bombings

Cited by 22 publications

References 29 publications

Externalizing the EU’s Justice and Home Affairs to Southeast Asia: Prospects and Limitations

Externalizing the EU’s Justice and Home Affairs to Southeast Asia: Prospects and Limitations

The Meaning of Religious Moderation on the Resilience of Muslim Minority in Balinese Hindus

The Structure of Coordination: Transatlantic Policy Networks and the Mobilization of Business and Civil Society

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About