The interpretation of low‐resistivity anomalies in the lithospheric mantle of several cratonic regions has invoked hydrogen, or connected networks of graphite with iron‐rich silicates, and/or metal sulfides. Electrical laboratory measurements are a powerful approach for exploring these alternatives. We report electrical measurements of two xenoliths (pyroxenite and dunite) from Tanzania; two metal sulfides (FeS and Fe‐S‐Ni); and several mixtures of metal sulfides (3.4–18.2 vol.%) with xenolith. A multi‐anvil press was employed to maintain a 2 GPa pressure and temperatures up to 1,627 K. The addition of 3.4 vol.% FeS to the pyroxenite or dunite matrix has little effect on bulk resistivity, particularly for T > 800 K. However, the resistivity drops dramatically–by factors of up to 1,000, depending on temperature–upon addition of 6.5 vol.% FeS in the dunite. Addition of 18.2% FeS causes a further decrease of the same magnitude relative to the 6.5% sample. Scanning electron microscope images do not reveal the formation of a connected FeS network as part of the decreased resistivity. Possible explanations for the apparently conflicting results include connections of the sulfide that are not imaged in the back‐scattered images, either because of limited resolution, or perhaps the inherent limitations of the 2‐D perspective. The complete data set (xenoliths, metal sulfides, and mixtures) was modeled with a modified version of Archie's law, and we find satisfactory agreement over a truncated temperature range. We conclude that the low‐resistivity anomalies in Tanzania, Kaapvaal, and Gawler cratons can be explained by the presence of a few vol.% of solid sulfide.