Hypoxia Preconditioned Plasma (HPP) and Serum (HPS) are regenerative blood-derived growth factor compositions that have been extensively examined for their angiogenic and lymphangiogenic activity towards wound healing and tissue repair. Optimization of these secretomes’ growth factor profile, through adjustments of the conditioning parameters, is a key step towards clinical application. In this study, the autologous liquid components (plasma/serum) of HPP and HPS were replaced with various conditioning media (NaCl, PBS, Glucose 5%, AIM V medium) and were analyzed in terms of key pro- (VEGF-A, EGF) and anti-angiogenic (TSP-1, PF-4) protein factors, as well as their ability to promote microvessel formation in vitro. We found that media substitution resulted in changes in the concentration of the aforementioned growth factors, and also influenced their ability to induce angiogenesis. While NaCl and PBS led to a lower concentration of all growth factors examined, and consequently an inferior tube formation response, replacement with Glucose 5% resulted in increased growth factor concentrations in anticoagulated blood-derived secretomes, likely due to stimulation of platelet factor release. Medium substitution with Glucose 5% and specialized peripheral blood cell-culture AIM V medium generated comparable tube formation to HPP and HPS controls. Altogether, our data suggest that medium replacement of plasma and serum may significantly influence the growth factor profile of hypoxia-preconditioned blood-derived secretomes and, therefore, their potential application as tools for promoting therapeutic angiogenesis.