T he notion that cardiovascular disease (CVD) remains a major burden to global morbidity and mortality has driven the quest for novel pharmaceutical agents to further reduce CVD risk. In this respect, cholesteryl ester transfer protein (CETP) has gained considerable interest, ever since one of the first descriptions in the 1980s that low CETP levels attributed to deleterious mutations in CETP were associated with longevity, 1 a finding that was later suggested to result from higher high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol (-C) levels.2 The role of HDL as a causal determinant in CVD risk, however, has not been established, and HDL-C levels might very well be a risk marker rather than a risk factor.
3,4
Response by Barter et al on p 440It is striking that 2 decades after the first description of the potential beneficial effects of CETP mutations, the effect of CETP on CVD risk remains inconclusive, and this, by itself, suggests that CETP may not be an attractive therapeutic target for the prevention of CVD. The hypothesis that CETP inhibition would result in CVD risk reduction has been questioned in the past. Fielding and Havel, 5 leading scientists in HDL metabolism, suggested that the increase in HDL-C induced by CETP inhibition could be misleading and in fact not be associated with CVD risk reduction. HDL particles formed on CETP inhibition are cholesteryl ester enriched and may lose their antiatherogenic bioactivity. Apart from insights from HDL metabolism, data derived from animal studies, large prospective human population studies, and clinical trials have generated conflicting results with respect to the role of CETP in CVD risk.We set out to summarize the published data that cast doubt on CETP as a therapeutic target to lower CVD risk. We focus on data derived from animal and human studies and we emphasize that the data presented are focused on the negative arguments, and these should be balanced against the arguments in favor of CETP inhibition described by Barter et al in this edition of Circulation.
6
CETP PhysiologyCETP, secreted by the liver, macrophages, and adipose tissue, plays a pivotal role in the transfer of cholesteryl esters from HDL to proatherogenic very low-density lipoprotein and lowdensity lipoprotein (LDL) particles in exchange for triglycerides (TGs). 7 The TG content in HDL particles is subsequently hydrolyzed by hepatic lipase. The transfer induced by CETP results in an increase of cholesterol within the LDL fraction and a decrease within HDL particles, especially in patients with elevated TG levels.