In Whose Interest? Gender and Mass–Elite Priority Congruence in Sub-Saharan Africa

Abstract

Do men and women representatives hold different legislative priorities? Do these priorities align with citizens who share their gender? Whereas substantive representation theorists suggest legislators' priorities should align with their cogender constituents, Downsian-based theories suggest no role for gender. We test these differing expectations through a new originally collected survey data set of more than 800 parliamentarians and data from more than 19,000 citizens from 17 sub-Saharan African countries. We find that whereas parliamentarians prioritize similar issues as citizens in general, important gender differences also emerge. Women representatives and women citizens are significantly more likely to prioritize poverty reduction, health care, and women's rights, whereas men representatives and men citizens tend to prioritize infrastructure projects. Examining variation in congruence between countries, we find that parliamentarians' and cogender citizens' priorities are most similar where democratic institutions are strongest. These results provide robust new evidence and insight into how and when legislator identity affects the representative process.

From Thin to Thick Representation: How a Female President Shapes Female Parliamentary Behavior

“…The literature on descriptive representation has highlighted the prevailing numeric underrepresentation of women in legislatures globally, but it has also particularly focused on how certain institutional solutions, such as gender quotas, may enhance the number of women in representative institutions (Tripp and Kang 2008). The literature on substantive representation, on the other hand, has focused more on how the interests of women citizens are advanced by increased female political representation Clayton et al 2019;Mansbridge 1999;Nwankwor 2019).…”

(How) Do Voters Discriminate Against Women Candidates? Experimental and Qualitative Evidence From Malawi

“…Research across a diverse set of cases suggests men and women citizens and politicians hold different policy priorities. The most consistently observed division in the developing world is men’s relative prioritization of infrastructure projects and women’s relative prioritization of access to potable water and improvements in women’s rights (Chattopadhyay & Duflo, 2004; Clayton, Josefsson, Mattes, & Mozaffar, 2018; Gottlieb, Grossman, & Robinson, 2018). 5 Citizens may expect councilors to represent gender-specific policy priorities (e.g., for men to prioritize infrastructure and women to prioritize water and issues related to women’s rights).…”

Gendered Accountability: When and Why Do Women's Policy Priorities Get Implemented?

“…In contrast, men are more likely to prioritize the management of the economy, infrastructure, agriculture, violence, and social and political rights. Clayton, Josefsson, Mattes and Mozaffar (2018) find support for such differences and also present evidence for mass-elite policy congruence along gendered lines.…”