Incentives and Prices for Motor Vehicles: What has been Happening in Recent Years?

Abstract

We address the construction of price indexes for consumer vehicles using data collected from a national sample of dealerships. The dataset contains highly disaggregate data on actual sales prices and quantities, along with information on customer cash rebates, financing terms, and much more. Using these data, we are able to capture the actual cash and financing incentives taken by consumers, and we demonstrate that their inclusion in measures of consumer vehicle prices is important. We also document other features of retail vehicle markets that interact and overlap with price measurement issues. In particular, we construct vehicle price indexes under different assumptions about what constitutes a Anew@ product in moving from one model year to the next. For the period that we study (1999 to 2003), a period during which incentives became more widespread and new model introductions rose, our preferred price index drops faster than the CPI for new vehicles.

The Price of Gasoline and the Demand for Fuel Economy: Evidence from Monthly New Vehicles Sales Data

“…11 The price of gasoline had a negligible effect on sales when it was low and relatively stable in the intervening years. As in Figure 4, the coefficient estimate is weakly positive in the early 1990s, but the magnitude is smaller than in the first and last periods and the standard errors are much larger.…”

“…It is unclear, though, how much of the changes in market shares is related to the change in the price of gasoline. 11 It is possible that the CAFE standard biases the results. A permanent increase in the price of gasoline would relax the constraint imposed by the standard because consumers would shift towards vehicles with high fuel economy.…”

Why are Inventory-Sales Ratios at U.S. Auto Dealerships so High?

“…Differentiation at the trim level covers product attributes such as engine size, power train, and major options packages. Paint color and other cosmetic choices add even more dimensions to product variety, and, as emphasized by Corrado, Dunn, and Otoo (2006), dealerships often hold and sell multiple model years of the same newly-produced vehicle at the same time.…”

Implications of Consumer Heterogeneity on Price Measures for Technology Goods

“…7 Specifically, we drop observations where the price paid is reported less than $100 and where the PC is younger than three years old at the time of the survey. We also isolate observations where the PC is used at home.…”