Incomplete knowledge: ethnography and the crisis of context in studies of media, science and technology

Abstract

This article examines strands of an intellectual history in Media and Cultural Studies and Science and Technology Studies in both of which researchers were prompted to take up ethnography. Three historical phases of this process are identified. The move between phases was the result of particular displacements and contestations of perspective in the research procedures within each discipline. Thus concerns about appropriate contextualization led to the eventual embrace of anthropological ethnographic methods. The article traces the subsequent emergence of a 'crisis of context' in the deployment of ethnography within these disciplines. The analysis of these historical changes is informed by a particular depiction of Euro-American knowledge conventions. The article suggests that the limits currently perceived for ethnography are a specific instance of the more general limits now recognized for these knowledge conventions.

Time, space and technology in radiotherapy departments: how do these factors impact on patients' experiences of radiotherapy?

“…). Ethnography recognises this increasing awareness of context (Morita ) and endeavours to make observations made in one setting or domain and connect them with a larger whole (Scheckler & Hirsch ). Observations, supported by interviews, enabled the culture of these radiation therapy departments to be revealed and critically scrutinised.…”

Laudable aims and problematic consequences, or: The ‘flow’ of knowledge is not neutral

“…7 The extent of anthropology's priority here is a matter of some contention (see Atkinson 1990;Atkinson and Hammersley 1994, among others). A fascinating and far from trivial account of the explicit adoption of 'ethnography' from anthropology (in this case by STS and media studies) is given by Schlecker and Hirsch (2001). 8 Gibbons et al .…”

Zines and Zones of Desire: Mass-Mediated Love, National Romance, and Sexual Citizenship in Gay Indonesia

“…A growing debate in media studies, sometimes called the "crisis of context," asks whether one can understand mass media in isolation from the everyday milieu in which they are produced and consumed (Schlecker and Hirsch 2001). Although fieldwork informs my analysis, I do not attempt to show that the cultural logics that I find in gay zines are present in other contexts.…”