Incorporating Virtual Reality to Improve Otolaryngology Resident Wellness: One Institution's Experience

Abstract

Objective Burnout is defined as work‐related emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and decreased sense of accomplishment. Virtual reality (VR) has emerged as an effective treatment modality for various conditions related to anxiety, however, few studies have assessed its role for stress management in residents. We hypothesize that VR‐based mindfulness meditation can reduce resident burnout in real‐world settings. Study Design Prospective randomized crossover trial. Methods Resident participants completed the validated Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI). One group used a VR‐based meditation app; the second group received no intervention. After a 2‐month rotation, all subjects completed an MBI and crossed over to the other arm. Wilcoxon rank‐sum tests were used to compare MBI scores before and after intervention, and to compare results by gender and postgraduate year. Mann‐Whitney U tests were used to assess qualitative differences between participants. Results Eighteen residents completed the study. Five participants were female and 13 were male. Weekly use of VR‐guided meditation and paced breathing was associated with a significant decrease in emotional exhaustion (P = .009), and on subgroup analysis, male gender specifically was associated with a decrease in emotional exhaustion (P = .027). In the post‐intervention survey, 42.9% subjects reported that VR encouraged them to employ paced breathing techniques, 71.4% reported that they would use the technology if regularly available, and 21.4% reported they would use paced breathing in the future. Conclusion VR‐based therapy may serve as a successful tool in stress management and reduce the rate of burnout among otolaryngology residents. Level of Evidence NA Laryngoscope, 131:1972–1976, 2021

Should Mindfulness for Health Care Workers Go Virtual? A Mindfulness-Based Intervention Using Virtual Reality and Heart Rate Variability in the Emergency Department

“…There are only a few MBI studies that have used VR-based guided meditations to promote well-being in the healthcare workplace—even fewer are studies that incorporate biomarkers such as HRV to measure physiologic effects on well-being that are not self-reported. In a 2021 prospective randomized crossover trial, Weitzman et al demonstrated a significant decrease in “emotional exhaustion” among male Otolaryngology residents compared with their female counterparts, after weekly use of VR-guided meditations over a 2-month period (Weitzman et al, 2021). While their study used the same Coresights TM VR meditation platform as in our study, they did not incorporate HRV analysis, as a measurement of relaxation.…”

Application of Virtual Reality Technology in Clinical Practice, Teaching, and Research in Complementary and Alternative Medicine

“…e prolonged illness and recovery time of COVID-19, coupled with infection prevention measures that make onsite family visits or movement between hospital units difficult or contraindicated, present a range of challenges for patients hospitalized with COVID-19, such as social isolation, disability, neurologic sequelae, adjustment-related anxiety, depression, stress, sleep disorders, and posttraumatic stress disorder [67]. It has been suggested that novel VR-based meditation interventions could be used as a comprehensive recovery program for COVID-19 [3,[63][64][65][66][67] and as successful stress management tools to reduce burnout rates among residents [30].…”

“…Third, COVID-19 has led to high levels of burnout and mental illness in medical students [ 29 ]. Mind-body interventions such as VR-based yoga [ 9 ] and mindfulness meditation [ 30 ] can be used as successful tools for stress management and the reduction of burnout rates and anxiety in resident physicians. VR can offer an immersive environment to enhance the user's experience and prevent distractions [ 31 ].…”

“…VR can offer an immersive environment to enhance the user's experience and prevent distractions [ 31 ]. Research studies showed that 10 minutes of VR therapy was similar in effect to reducing work by 1.6 hours per week with regard to reductions in emotional exhaustion [ 30 ]. To this end, an important benefit of VR is the minimal time commitment necessary, allowing medical residents to benefit from decreased burnout without losing important educational opportunities [ 30 ].…”

"A Pilot Project in Primary Care- Using Virtual Reality Guided Meditation Sessions to Reduce the Burnout of Health Workers"

“…The medical and healthcare field is one of the fastest growing in the use of these new tools. In many organizations it has become a very important resource to address and improve the quality of the work environment [8]. Virtual reality (VR) is a simulated experience that can be similar to or completely different from the real world.…”