In our study, we aimed to show how different reaction parameters can affect the production rates using photocatalytic hydrogen peroxide formation by different polymeric carbon nitrides (PCN). For this purpose, selected materials were first compared at the same reaction conditions and compared with TiO2 (P25). We also show that different light intensities can have a different influence on seemingly similar materials. Since hydrogen peroxide production in the presence of an electron donor proceeds mainly by reduction of oxygen, we also show an influence of the oxygen flow on the formation rates. Thus, with high oxygen fluxes and high intensities of irradiated light, we were able to achieve an H2O2 concentration of 125 mM after about 25 h. Finally, the two best PCN materials were selected to measure light intensity dependence at different wavelengths up to visible light. It was found that they behaved differently at the different wavelengths and thus it could be shown that an exact specification of the reaction parameters is indispensable for comparisons in the literature.