Perturbations in naive T cell homeostasis and function may play a major role in the immunodeficiency that accompanies HIV infection. By examining naive CD4+ T cell function on a single cell basis, we provide evidence that these cells have significant qualitative defects in HIV disease. Ki67, a molecule expressed during cell cycle progression, is induced less efficiently among naive CD4+ T cells from HIV-infected individuals following activation with anti-TCR Ab. The impairment in Ki67 expression is evident even when a separate function, CD62L down-modulation, is within normal ranges. Moreover, the defects in Ki67 induction are only sometimes corrected by the addition of rIL-2 to cell cultures. An initial assessment of IL-2 unresponsiveness in cells from selected HIV-infected individuals suggests that the defect is not a consequence of impaired IL-2R expression or IL-2R signaling capability. Qualitative defects in naive T cells that cannot be routinely corrected by IL-2 have significant implications for disease pathogenesis and for strategies using IL-2 as a vaccine adjuvant in HIV disease.