“…Second, there are unique justifications in excise levy, which are: (i) controlling the consumption of a certain type of goods (Schafferer et al, 2018;Shang et al, 2019;Bridge et al, 2020); (ii) internalizing negative externality (Alvarez, 2019;di Bella et al, 2019;Quiggin & Wang, 2019;Nwadialor & Agbo, 2020;(iii) increasing the efficiency of resources (Akhmetshin et al, 2019;Becker et al, 2019;Sugiyama & Koonsed, 2019); (iv) creating jobs (Friske & Cockrell, 2019, Kitchen et al, 2019Nguyen et al, 2020); and (v) increasing government income; among others (Ross et al, 2017;Alsukait et al, 2019;Luong & Vu, 2020). Those reasons make excise tax different with any other tax, since normally government income is used as the main justification in every tax levy.…”