Introduction: Spinal intradural tumors account for 15% of all CNS tumors. Typical tumor entities include ependymomas, astrocytomas, meningiomas, and neurinomas. In cases of multiple affected segments, extensive approaches may be necessary to achieve the gold standard of complete tumor resection. Methods: We performed a bicentric, retrospective cohort study of all patients equal to or older than 14 years who underwent multi-segment surgical treatment for spinal intradural tumors between 2007 and 2023 with approaches longer than four segments without instrumentation. We assessed the surgical technique and the clinical outcome regarding signs of symptomatic spinal instability. Children were excluded from our cohort. Results: In total, we analyzed 33 patients with a median age of 44 years and interquartile range IQR of 30–56 years, including the following tumors: 21 ependymomas, one subependymoma–ependymoma mixed tumor, two meningiomas, two astrocytomas, and seven patients with other entities. The median length of the approach was five spinal segments with a range of 4–14 and with the foremost localization in the cervical or thoracic spine. Laminoplasty was the most chosen approach (72.2%). The median time to follow-up was 13 months IQR (4–56 months). Comparing pre- and post-surgery outcomes, 72.2% of the patients (n = 24) reported pain improvement after surgery. The median modified McCormick scores pre- and post surgery were equal to II IQR (I–II) and II IQR (I–III), respectively. Discussion: We achieved satisfying results with long-segment approaches. In general, patients reported pain improvement after surgery and received similar low modified McCormick scores pre- and post surgery and did not undergo secondary dorsal fixation. Thus, we conclude that intradural tumor resection via extensive approaches does not seem to impair long-term spinal stability in our cohort.