Indicators for the on-farm assessment of crop cultivar and livestock breed diversity: a survey-based participatory approach

Abstract

Last, L., Arndorfer, M., Bal?zs, K., Dennis, P., Dyman, T., Fjellstad, W., Friedel, J. K., Herzog, F., Jeanneret, P., Luscher, G., Moreno, G., Kwikiriza, N., Gomiero, T., Paoletti, M., Pointereau, P., Sarthou, J-P., Stoyanova, S., Wolfrum, S., K?lliker, R. (2014). Indicators for the on-farm assessment of crop cultivar and livestock breed diversity: a survey-based participatory approach. Biodiversity and Conservation, 23 (12), 3051-3071Agrobiodiversity plays a fundamental role in guaranteeing food security. However, still little is known about the diversity within crop and livestock species: the genetic diversity. In this paper we present a set of indicators of crop accession and breed diversity for different farm types at farm-level, which may potentially supply a useful tool to assess and monitor farming system agrobiodiversity in a feasible and relatively affordable way. A generic questionnaire was developed to capture the information on crops and livestock in 12 European case study regions and in Uganda by 203 on-farm interviews. Through a participatory approach, which involved a number of stakeholders, eight potential indicators were selected and tested. Five of them are recommended as potentially useful indicators for agrobiodiversity monitoring per farm: (1) crop-species richness (up to 16 crop species), (2) crop-cultivar diversity (up to 15 crop cultivars, 1?2 on average), (3) type of crop accessions (landraces accounted for 3 % of all crop cultivars in Europe, 31 % in Uganda), (4) livestock-species diversity (up to 5 livestock species), and (5) breed diversity (up to five cattle and eight sheep breeds, on average 1?2).We demonstrated that the selected indicators are able to detect differences between farms, regions and dominant farm types. Given the present rate of agrobiodiversity loss and the dramatic effects that this may have on food production and food security, extensive monitoring is urgent. A consistent survey of crop cultivars and livestock breeds on-farm will detect losses and help to improve strategies for the management and conservation of on-farm genetic resources.authorsversionPeer reviewe

Evolution of Rural Livelihood Strategies in a Remote Sino-Mongolian Border Area: A Cross-Country Analysis

“…[70]), the application of this approach is under-utilised in livestock-related research [71,72]. Recently, [73] proposed livestock species richness (one indicator out of five) to easily assess agrobiodiversity on a farm scale. As our results show, livestock species richness can be reliably determined from a sample of thirty herds in the study area.…”

Implications of Smallholder Farm Production Diversity for Household Food Consumption Diversity: Insights from Diverse Agro-Ecological and Market Access Contexts in Rural Tanzania

“…With respect to farm production diversity, we use two indicators. The first is based on species count for both crops and livestock, as recommended by Last et al [34] and used in several recent studies (see, for example, Jones et al [3]; Pellegrini and Tasciotti [8]; Sibhatu et al [9]). In this indicator, a household cultivating three crops (e.g., maize, sorghum and groundnuts) and keeping cattle only will have a crop-livestock count of 4.…”

Assessing the Effectiveness of Projects Supporting On-Farm Conservation of Native Crops: Evidence From the High Andes of South America

“…This index builds on the "crop-cultivar diversity" index (sum of all varieties of all crops present in a farm) proposed by Last et al (2014), but by using factor analysis, our index takes into consideration the underlying structure of the distribution of cultivars across crops. In all cases, the index used here, the crop-cultivar diversity index, and the number of varieties of each crop per household are highly and positively correlated in a statistically significant way, except for our index and olluco in project B (results not shown).…”