Indigenous epistemology in a national curriculum framework?

Abstract

In this article, a group of four indigenous Māori educators and one non-Māori educator comment on a proposed amendment to the New Zealand National Curriculum Framework to replace the current separate sets of skills, values and attitudes with five generic performance-based key competencies. The paper discusses important parallels between western/European sociocultural theorizing on human development and learning (on which the key competencies seemed to be based), and the values, beliefs and preferred practices that are embodied within an indigenous Māori cultural worldview ( Te Ao Māori). A Māori worldview is characterized by an abiding concern for the quality of human relationships that need to be established and maintained if learning contexts are to be effective for Māori students, and for these relationships to balance individual learning and achievement against responsibilities for the well-being and achievement of the group. Within such a worldview, education is understood as holistic, collective, experiential and dependent upon a free exchanging of teaching and learning roles. The article describes five specific cultural constructs within this worldview that highlight Māori traditional understandings of human development and learning and teaching, and aligns and compares these constructs with the five key competencies proposed. The article argues that the worldviews of Māori people in New Zealand provide an extensive and coherent framework for theorizing about human development and education, and are able to contribute strongly and positively to the development of a national school curriculum for the benefit all students. Implications for other contexts can also be drawn.

An Analysis of Ontario Aboriginal Education Policy: Critical and interpretive perspectives

“…The problems within this identity discourse, incidentally, are equally applicable to the Aboriginal students themselves. Their experience in public school consti- tutes a significant part of their life experiences and includes opportunities to self reflect, develop functional socio-emotional skills, and adapt to mainstream institutional expectations and values (Macfarlane, Glynn, Grace, Penetito, & Bateman, 2008). This necessitates that Aboriginal youth negotiate their bicultural identities by making sense of the beliefs, relationships, and practices of school and curriculum in light of their traditional teachings and worldviews (Lutz & Ledema, 2004).…”

Positive youth development in Māori and New Zealand European adolescents through an adventure education programme

“…The youth who take part are predominantly Māori. With respect to the voyage, there are a number of important aspects that link with the concepts of whanaungatanga and collective identity (Macfarlane et al 2008) and place (Brown 2008). For example, there is a particular emphasis on linking the sea and voyaging tradition back to youth's ancestors, noting that their tupuna (ancestors) would have sailed on schooners similar to the R. Tucker Thompson.…”

Creating peaceful and effective schools through a culture of care

“…A person's collective identity is also strongly defined in association with people who descend from specific important ancestors and who affiliate with particular geographic locations and landscape features (Glynn, Cowie, Otrel-Cass, & Macfarlane, 2010;Macfarlane, Glynn, Grace, Penetito, & Bateman, 2008). Traditionally, maintaining these relationships was central to maintaining one's identity, and indeed central to one's safety and survival.…”