Individual investor biases: a segmentation analysis

Abstract

PurposeIndian investors have been exposed to a plethora of investment opportunities in the past decade and a half, after the liberalization process which commenced in 1991. Over the years, the increased competition has brought a wind of change, not just in the economic environment within the country, but also a radical change in the choices and preferences of the financial consumers. In the endeavor to provide more personalized advice to the financial consumers, financial service providers need more insights into the minds of the consumers. However, little work has been done to understand the Indian individual investor. The purpose of this paper is to study the Individual investor in India: to segment the investor into distinct behavioural groups based on their biases; to understand the investment preferences and profile of the identified segments; and to understand the implications for financial services providers.Design/methodology/approachExploratory research, using In‐depth interviews, was undertaken to explore the manifestations of the biases among the individual investors. The initial inventory of 97 items pertaining to biases was assessed for content and face validity and subject to pilot test and subsequent rounds of modification. The final data were collected on a sample of 377 respondents, using a questionnaire that captured eight biases: Reliance on experts; Overconfidence bias; Self‐control bias; Categorisation tendency; Budgeting tendency; Adaptive tendency; Socially responsible investing bias; and Spouse effect. The segments of investor biases were identified using cluster analysis.FindingsA cluster analysis of data, collected from individual investors was conducted in India (n=377), yielded four main segments of individual investors biases, which have been termed as the Novice Learner, the Competent Confirmer, the Cautious Anticipator and the Efficient Planner. This typology has predictive validity with regard to financial satisfaction and perceived financial market knowledge.Practical implicationsThe paper presents a very important practical tool which can help financial service providers define their target audience more sharply and understand how people in these segments differ, behaviorally. Better understanding of investor's perceptions would help in designing more attractive financial products and development of marketing strategies that would impact the customer's financial satisfaction levels and create trust and customer loyalty.Originality/valueThis paper is a first of its kind to empirically identify the segments of biased behavior among investors and contributes to furthering the understanding on investor behavior.

Do Investors’ Exhibit Cognitive Biases: Evidence From Indian Equity Market

“…Optimism bias and disposition effect have the highest mean scores of 4.687 and 4.381 which firstly indicates that majority of equity investors in India believe that they are more likely to experience good outcomes over bad ones and secondly, that they are prone to sell such stocks quite at early stage which has increased in value since purchase, instead the one fallen in value and vice-versa. The results are similar with the earlier studies (Sahi and Arora, 2012;Mishra and Metilda, 2015;Prosad et al, 2015;Kumar and Goyal, 2016).…”

“…Further, Mumbai being 37 th largest city by GDP and economic and commercial centre of India was selected for study, wherein a normal individual is financially capable to invest in equity market. As any authorized list of investors was not accessible, the investigation trails the approach recommended by earlier investigators (Gupta 1991; Davar and Gill 2007;Sahi and Arora 2012). The present study is based on snowball and chain referral sampling technique which is used when there is difficulty to obtain access to the population under study due to legal, social or moral constraints (Biernacki and Waldorf 1981).…”

Factors Influencing Retail Investors’ Trading Behaviour in the Thai Stock Market

“…As per the objective of this study, only a specific segment of the population is of interest. Consequently, the data have been collected subjectively but from a relevant segment of the population (Prosad et al, 2015;Shalini & Ashok, 2012). In this case, the target respondents are people who invest, that is, people with savings and the capacity to invest in various financial segments.…”

Modelling the Effects of Financial Services Advertising on Financial Product Purchase: An Empirical Validation

“…Whereas Hassan et al (2009) opined that women have less financial literacy as compared to men. Also, married women they rely more on the spouse (Kalra & Arora, 2012).…”