Industry Clusters and Regional Economic Performance: A Study Across U.S. Metropolitan Statistical Areas

Abstract

For over two decades, policy makers and economic development professionals have stressed the importance of encouraging and supporting industry clusters to promote job creation and regional competitiveness. Several researchers-Michael Porter and Christian Ketels, among others-have developed the study of cluster-based economic development and touted the employment and competitive benefits of cluster-based development strategies (Ketels, 2013; Ketels & Memedovic, 2008; Porter, 2008). Several studies have quantified the benefits of clusters in terms of employment growth and competitiveness as it relates to patent rates, with Delgado, Porter, and Stern (2014) being the most comprehensive. Yet other economic benefits along the dimensions of productivity, wage, and income growth have been largely overlooked. In this study, we assess the benefits of clusters across several traditional measures of economic performance. This study is organized as follows: We first discuss key concepts related to clusters in a brief literature review, including a discussion on the role of related and unrelated variety as they are connected to cluster definitions. Second, we present the data, analytical methods, and the rationale and construction for three measures of regional cluster characteristics, namely strength, diversity, and growth. These three measures are applied to both traded and local/nontraded clusters. The third section reports the empirical results, with the fourth section discussing the findings and conclusions about the usefulness of our measures. Review of the Literature Industry clusters are agglomerations of closely related industries (Delgado, Porter, & Stern, 2010). One might say that clusters are a network of economic relationships that create a competitive advantage for the related firms in a particular region. This advantage then becomes an enticement for similar industries to develop or relocate to a region. Developing industry clusters has become a key goal for regional economic development, as clusters have been shown to strengthen competitiveness by increasing productivity, stimulating innovative new partnerships (even among competitors), and presenting opportunities for new businesses.

How do Clusters Foster Sustainable Development? An Analysis of EU Policies

“…As the effect of the EU activities, the European Cluster Alliance was established, constituting a network of institutions representing central and regional authorities and development agencies that support transnational cooperation between regions in the field of cluster policy development. The main aim of EU actions is to intensify cluster and business network collaboration across borders and sectoral boundaries [58]. The EU actions enable European cluster cooperation, exchange of knowledge and experience by participation in international projects.…”

Identifying resilient industries in Mexico's automotive cluster: Policy lessons from the great recession to surmount the crisis caused by COVID 19

“…We propose a notion of resilience more oriented to examining the distributional effects of recovery, the contagion of resilience. Slaper et al (2018) ground the concept of resilience on the notion of diversification of related industries in a cluster instead of mere specialization. Resilience allows for complementarities and inter-industry collaboration.…”

“…This study also employs the concept of industrial clusters to examine the capacity of the automotive industries in Mexico to generate employment, promote competitiveness and boost economic development (Ketels, 2013;Ketels & Memedovic, 2008). Besides examining the potential to increase productivity, stimulate innovation, and generate new business opportunities, the analysis of resilience in this study offers a solid base to analyze spatial autocorrelation (Slaper et al, 2018). Brown and Greenbaum (2016) explore employment resilience, concentration, and diversity over time in Ohio, and find that regions with more diverse industrial structures performed better after adverse economic shocks.…”

Biomass Clusters as a National Energy Security Factor

“…Alongside other business clusters, the biomass cluster may decrease incentives for new business formation due to increased competition and crowdingout effects (or congestion costs) that result in diminishing marginal returns to entrepreneurial opportunities. Others claim clusters might lower the cost of starting a business by providing specialized suppliers, a local customer base, and producers of complementary products and services (Slaper, Harmon, Rubin, 2016). This is an additional activity efficiency trend -a cluster, generating resources of own members, refers them to the direction which would assure the lowest product's cost-price and would maximise the cluster members' benefit.…”