Inferencing Abilities of Deaf College Students: Foundations and Implications for Metaphor Comprehension and Theory of Mind

Abstract

Understanding nonliteral language requires inferencing ability and is an important but complex aspect of social interaction, involving cognitive (e.g., theory of mind, executive function) as well as language skill, areas in which many deaf individuals struggle. This study examined comprehension of metaphor and sarcasm, assessing the contributions of hearing status, inferencing ability, executive function (verbal short-term/working memory capacity), and deaf individuals' communication skills (spoken versus signed language, cochlear implant use). Deaf and hearing college students completed a multiple-choice metaphor comprehension task and inferencing tasks that included both social-emotional (i.e., theory of mind) and neutral inferences, as well as short-term memory span and working memory tasks. Results indicated the hearing students to have better comprehension of nonliteral language and the ability to make social-emotional inferences, as well as greater memory capacity. Deaf students evidenced strong relationships among inferential comprehension, communication skills, and memory capacity, with substantial proportions of the variance in understanding of metaphor and sarcasm accounted for by these variables. The results of this study enhance understanding of the language and cognitive skills underlying figurative language comprehension and theory of mind and have implications for the social functioning of deaf individuals.

Training deaf college students to improve their theory of mind: based on a two-component model

“…The results showed that these individuals scored significantly lower on all three ToM tests than their hearing peers. The same results were found in Edwards et al (2021) , where deaf college students performed worse than their hearing peers on sarcasm, metaphor comprehension tasks, and reasoning tasks.…”

The Impact of Executive Dysfunction on Anxiety in Hearing-Impaired College Students: Smartphone Addiction as a Mediator and Academic Procrastination as a Moderator

“… 46 , 47 This shift in information acquisition has increased their cognitive load. 6 Additionally, executive functioning, a cognitive domain affected by auditory deprivation, further limits their ability to process complex information and make decisions. 48 When faced with heavy academic pressure, social challenges, or uncertainty about the future, college students with hearing loss may feel overwhelmed, resulting in anxiety.…”

“… 4 , 5 Research has shown that college students with hearing impairments often exhibit significant deficits in working memory, including verbal memory span and verbal working memory capacity, which are related to executive function. 6 These students often struggle with understanding verbal instructions, processing information, and mastering social norms when completing tasks and making plans. Similar to their normal-hearing peers, hearing-impaired college students are at a critical stage in their lives, facing various academic, professional, and social challenges.…”

Understanding cultural aspects of deaf communities in México towards the codesign of automatic sign language processing systems

“…Another limitation was the use of a metaphor artifact, which caused some difficulties for participants to understand what was being asked as examples. In a recent study, Edwards et al (2021)) compared metaphor comprehension among deaf and hearing students, reporting a better understanding of nonliteral language among hearing participants. Based on that, further reflection on the continuity of using this approach should be weighted.…”