Hi‐Nicalon™‐S SiC fiber was heat treated for 1 hour at 1300°C, 1400°C, and 1500°C in argon with pO2 of 3.7, 10, 20, 50, 100, and 200 ppm. Fiber strengths were measured by 30 single‐filament tensile tests. Fiber microstructure and surface morphology were characterized by TEM. Active oxidation occurred in all cases except at 1500°C with 200 ppm pO2, 1400°C with 100 ppm pO2 or higher, and 1300°C with 50 ppm pO2 or higher. When active oxidation did not occur, a glass SiO2 scale formed at 1300°C and 1400°C, and a cristobalite scale formed at 1500°C. The thickness of these scales was much larger than that predicted by linear dependence of oxidation rate on pO2. Fiber strengths were lowest after heat treatment at 1300°C and a pO2 of 3.7 ppm, 1400°C and a pO2 of 20 ppm, and 1500°C and a pO2 of 200 ppm. Active oxidation caused fiber surface roughening, but no obvious changes to the internal fiber microstructure. Decreased fiber strength correlated with increased fiber surface roughness, but roughness magnitudes were not large enough to explain the amount by which strength was degraded. Fiber strengths, surface roughness, scale thicknesses, and the passive‐active oxidation transition for SiC are compared with previous observations. Possible strength degradation mechanisms are discussed.