Internal damage accumulation is measured and shown to play a role in the mechanical response of replicated pure Al and Al12Si open-cell foams. This internal damage is quantified by measuring the reduction in the foamÕs stiffness with strain. The brittle Si second phase fractures during deformation of Al-12Si foam, resulting in damage accumulation rates an order of magnitude greater than for pure Al foam. Elementary damage mechanics is used to relate the measured rate of damage accumulation to the foamÕs tensile failure strain. The analysis and experimental results highlight in particular the strong embrittling influence of brittle second phases within the foam, such as Si.