Influence of Functional Rider and Horse Asymmetries on Saddle Force Distribution During Stance and in Sitting Trot

Abstract

Asymmetric forces exerted on the horse's back during riding are assumed to have a negative effect on rider-horse interaction and health of the horse. Visualized on a saddle pressure mat they are initially blamed on a non-fitting saddle. The contribution of horse and rider to an asymmetric loading pattern, however, is not well understood. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of horse and rider asymmetries during stance and in sitting trot on the force distribution on the horse's back using a saddle pressure mat and motion capture analysis simultaneously. Data of 80 horse-rider pairs (HRP) were collected and analyzed using linear (mixed) models to determine the influence of rider and horse variables on asymmetric force distribution. Both, rider and horse variables revealed significant relationships to asymmetric saddle force distribution (P<0.001). During sitting trot, the collapse of the rider in one hip increased the force on the contralateral side and the tilt of the rider's upper body to one side led to more force on the same side of the pressure mat. Analyzing different subsets of data revealed that rider posture as well as horse movements and conformation can cause an asymmetric loading pattern. Since neither horse nor rider movement can be assessed independently during riding, the interpretation of an asymmetric force distribution on the saddle pressure mat remains challenging and all contributing factors (horse, rider, saddle) need to be considered.

An investigation into the association of the physical fitness of equestrians and their riding performance: a cross-sectional study

“…Various authors have recognized equestrian's asymmetry and its relation to saddle pressure distribution, seated postural stability, and potentially musculoskeletal pain, this study did not confirm the assumption that asymmetry is a negative predictor for RP (Gunst et al, 2019;Hobbs et al, 2014;Nevison and Timmis, 2013).…”

Evaluating the suitability of an English saddle for a horse and rider combination

“…Regardless of the cause, repeated saddle slip results in increased pressure under the front quadrant of the saddle (Greve and Dyson ), either on the contralateral side (which may be associated with rider crookedness and ‘collapse of one hip’) or on the ipsilateral (associated with tilt of the rider; Gunst et al . ).…”

Relationships between the Rider’s Pelvic Mobility and Balance on a Gymnastic Ball with Equestrian Skills and Effects on Horse Welfare

“…Ideally, as the rider's pelvis tilts from anterior to posterior, there is a small amount of lateral roll [5], whilst the trunk maintains its vertical posture and the head keeps a stiller and more consistent horizontal posture [22]. Adjustments of pelvic and trunk posture affect pressure distribution beneath the saddle [23,24], which is perceived by the horse and may affect the horses' balance [25] and perhaps result in the horse showing conflict behaviors. Skilled riders move the pelvis independent of the other body segments, which requires good dynamic postural control [6] to create a more harmonious relationship with the horse [5,26] and earn high scores in competition [26].…”