“…To date, it is generally believed that hydrogen bubble nucleation by self-clustering like the case of helium in metals [5,6] would be impossible given the H-H strong repulsion or very weak attraction in metals [7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14], and that, as suggested by many previous studies [4,7,8,10,11], hydrogen bubble nucleation would require the presence of lattice defects. The hydrogen bubble nucleation can be either heterogeneous, relating to grain boundaries, [15][16][17][18] dislocations, [18] and impurities, [7,19] or homogeneous, arising from the aggregation of vacancies or vacancy-hydrogen complexes. [20,21] However, hydrogen bubble formation in metals with extremely low concentration of the lattice defects has been clearly observed in many experiments.…”