Settlement control of existing stations has consistently been a key issue in tunnel construction. Intermediate soil has a significant influence on the settlement of the existing station as a connector between the new tunnel and the existing station which should be considered when selecting settlement control measures. To clarify the relationship between the state of the intermediate soil and the settlement and control measures of the existing station, this study investigated 49 new tunnel projects under existing stations and elucidated the relationship between the settlement and the settlement control measures of the existing station and the intermediate soil. The relationship between the failure of the intermediate soil and the settlement of the existing station was further analyzed by numerical simulation. Lastly, a simple mechanical model of intermediate soil failure was constructed to determine the stress state of the intermediate soil in constructing a tunnel under the existing station to guide the formulation of settlement control measures for the existing station. Hence, when the intermediate soil is completely destroyed, active control measures, such as jack or grouting lifting, should be implemented; when the intermediate soil is partially damaged, passive control measures should be undertaken. Thus, this study can provide a reference for settlement control of tunnels under existing stations.