An electro-fragmentation method was developed as a fast alternative to the time consuming fragmentation test carried out in situ in a microscope, to investigate the failure of dielectric inorganic coatings on polymer substrates. An ultrathin conductive layer was used to probe the onset of tensile failure in the dielectric coating through changes of its electrical resistance. A careful selection of the conductive layer has been carried out to avoid artifacts resulting for instance from a change of the cohesive properties (e.g. internal stress state) of the investigated structures. Au layers were found to be too ductile, contrary to Al-Ti layers that were too brittle, which invalidated the use of both materials to probe the failure of the dielectric coatings. In contrast, for structures on high-temperature polymer substrates, a 10 nm thick amorphous graphite (a-G) layer was found to accurately reproduce the cracking of the coating. The Young's modulus and coefficient of thermal expansion of the a-G layer are low enough not to impact the internal strain, hence the crack onset strain of the dielectric coating. The a-G layer is also sufficiently brittle, and its cohesive failure and resulting increase of electrical resistance is triggered by the failure of the dielectric coating. The a-G electro-fragmentation method is presently limited to polymers substrates with a glass-transition temperature higher than 100°C.