Influence of the EU Chemicals Regulation on the US Policy Reform Debate: Is a ‘California Effect’ within REACH?

Abstract

In 2006, the EU adopted the REACH Regulationthe world's most demanding chemicals regime so far. Even before it entered into force, the European Commission declared its ambition to make REACH a global standard, and several authors see a potential for far-reaching influence via the 'California effect', as conceptualized by David Vogel. Economic preconditions are indeed fulfilled with the chemicals industry being highly globalized, the EU as an attractive export market and REACH applying to imports. Following Vogel, firms exporting to the EU might have an incentive to lobby for similar requirements in their country. This article examines whether American chemical producers do, indeed, push for EU-like provisions in the debate on US policy reform. While there is some influence on the US, it is shown that REACH does not (yet) trigger a 'California effect'. The business case does not seem to be strong enough.

Environmental Law as a Transnational Ecosystem

“…dissertation as a peerreviewed article and, thanks to TEL, it is a privilege that I have experienced more than once. Dirk Heyen, 40 Cordelia Bähr, 41 Roderic O'Gorman 42 and Alexia Staker are all former LSE Masters' students who have published excellent research in TEL, and shortly thereafter Alexia joined TEL's Assistant Editorial team, where she continues to do a sterling job to this day. Her article is an eloquent representation both of TEL's keen interest in supporting early career scholars, and of the boundary-pushing research that it champions.…”

Raising Awareness on Health Impact of the Chemicals Used in Consumer Products: Empirical Evidence from East-Central Europe

“…Although this is an ongoing concern for academic researchers, recent studies demonstrate that knowledge on the hazards and risks associated with the use of chemicals continues to be very limited [5,28].…”

“…In Europe, regulations on the Registration, Evaluation, Authorization and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) were introduced in 2007 by the European Chemicals Agency. Researchers analyzed these two regulations and agreed that regulatory standards in Europe are tighter [5,26] and more easily accessible by consumers than their American equivalents [28]. Chemical manufacturers, however, favor US regulations when compared to the EU [2].…”

Norms, Networks, and Markets: Navigating New Frontiers in Transnational Environmental Law

“…22 In July 2013, Dirk Heyen blogged 'REACH Hardly Reaching into US Chemicals Regulation Reform', 23 following up on the latest US political developments since the publication of his recent article in TEL issue 2(1). 24 Further innovations and new features will be introduced with the coming issues.…”