Influenza Outbreak during Sydney World Youth Day 2008: The Utility of Laboratory Testing and Case Definitions on Mass Gathering Outbreak Containment

Abstract

BackgroundInfluenza causes annual epidemics and often results in extensive outbreaks in closed communities. To minimize transmission, a range of interventions have been suggested. For these to be effective, an accurate and timely diagnosis of influenza is required. This is confirmed by a positive laboratory test result in an individual whose symptoms are consistent with a predefined clinical case definition. However, the utility of these clinical case definitions and laboratory testing in mass gathering outbreaks remains unknown.Methods and ResultsAn influenza outbreak was identified during World Youth Day 2008 in Sydney. From the data collected on pilgrims presenting to a single clinic, a Markov model was developed and validated against the actual epidemic curve. Simulations were performed to examine the utility of different clinical case definitions and laboratory testing strategies for containment of influenza outbreaks. Clinical case definitions were found to have the greatest impact on averting further cases with no added benefit when combined with any laboratory test. Although nucleic acid testing (NAT) demonstrated higher utility than indirect immunofluorescence antigen or on-site point-of-care testing, this effect was lost when laboratory NAT turnaround times was included. The main benefit of laboratory confirmation was limited to identification of true influenza cases amenable to interventions such as antiviral therapy.ConclusionsContinuous re-evaluation of case definitions and laboratory testing strategies are essential for effective management of influenza outbreaks during mass gatherings.

A systematic review of emerging respiratory viruses at the Hajj and possible coinfection with Streptococcus pneumoniae

“…The majority of viral respiratory infections acquired during pilgrimage are due to influenza viruses, and rhinoviruses [64]. The diagnosis of seasonal influenza during the hajj was a major focus of most studies addressing the prevalence of respiratory viruses among pilgrims [23,25,[32][33][34]36,39,40,43,56,[68][69][70][71][72][73][74][75][76][77][78][79][80]. In these studies, different methods were used to detect respiratory viruses, with PCR being the most common used method.…”

Simulation of pooled-sample analysis strategies for COVID-19 mass testing

“…Computer simulations are common tools for the assessment of the cost-effectiveness of PCR pooled samples screening [23,24,25,26]. Owing to the wide range of uncertain parameters in the current COVID-19 pandemic, we applied Monte Carlo simulation techniques to enable the comparison of the effect of the two mass testing strategies on the required number of tests [27,28].…”

Protocol for a randomised controlled trial examining the impact of a web-based personally controlled health management system on the uptake of influenza vaccination rates

“…Febrile upper respiratory tract illnesses occurring during the peak influenza period was identified as the most specific clinical case definition expected to have the highest positive predictive value for true influenza [18]. …”