Information control by public punishment: The logic of signalling repression in China

Abstract

When does repression of online expression lead to public punishment of citizens in China? Chinese social media is heavily censored through a system of intermediary liability in which the government relies on private companies to implement content controls. Outside of this system the Chinese authorities at times utilize public punishment to repress social media users. Under China’s regulatory environment, individuals are subject to punishment such as fines and detention for their expressions online. While censorship has become more implicit, authorities have periodically announced cases of repression to the public. To understand when the state escalates from censoring online content to punishing social media users for their online expressions and publicizes the punishment, we collected 468 cases of state repression announced by the authorities between 1 January 2014 and 1 April 2019. We find that the Chinese authorities most frequently publicize persecutions of citizens who posted online expression deemed critical of the government or those that challenged government credibility. These cases show more evidence of the state pushing the responsibility of ‘self-regulation’ further to average citizens. By making an example of individuals who post prohibited content even in semi-public social media venues, the state signals strength and its determination to maintain authority.

The “Parallel Pandemic” in the Context of China: The Spread of Rumors and Rumor-Corrections During COVID-19 in Chinese Social Media

“…Chinese officials and social media companies claim to have made substantial efforts to correct widespread false information and recalibrate public discourse about COVID-19. In the early days of the crisis, Chinese authorities tightened social media censorship to curb alerts to the public on the threat of the then-unknown virus ( Ruan et al, 2019 ). As the pandemic developed, social media platforms worked to identify and vet rumors through government-backed entities supervised by the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC).…”

The transnationality of mobile media and contemporary racisms: A future research agenda

“…Here, the focus is on how the male foreigners—all of whom live in China—are forced to use the mega app. They are then also forced to accede to the socio-political values embedded in the app, including amongst many things the Chinese state's stance on censorship of political speech (see Ruan et al, 2021).…”

Unpacking government social media messaging strategies during the COVID‐19 pandemic in China

“…During the Wuhan lockdown, almost all Chinese people paid attention to the situation in the city and expressed their worries and concerns. A flood of criticism, anger, blame, and frustration with the government appeared online even though social media platforms were subject to censorship (Ruan et al, 2020). Netizens’ responses prompted the government to acknowledge that public criticism of the outbreak was understandable (Cadell & Liu, 2020) and to respond to the epidemic.…”