Information triangulation: A complex and agentic everyday information practice

Abstract

In contemporary urban settings, information seekers may face challenges assessing and making use of the large quantity of information to which they have access. Such challenges may be particularly acute when laypeople are considering specialized or technical information pertaining to topics over which knowledge is contested. Within a constructivist grounded theory study of the health information practices of 39 young parents in urban Canada, a complex practice of information triangulation was observed. Triangulation comprised an iterative process of seeking, assessment, and sense-making, and typically resulted in a decision or action. This paper examines the emergent concept of information triangulation in everyday life, using data from the young parent study. Triangulation processes in this study could be classified as one of four types, and functioned as an exercise of agency in the face of structures of expertise and exclusion. Although triangulation has long been described and discussed as a practice among scientific researchers wishing to validate and enrich their data, it has rarely been identified as an everyday practice in information behavior research. Future investigations should consider the use of information triangulation for other types of information, including by other populations and in other areas of contested knowledge.

COVID-19 Communication Ecology: Visualizing Communication Resource Connections During a Public Health Emergency Using Network Analysis

“…This is because use of multiple communication resources, compared with use of a single or a few communication resources, may provide an individual with additional information that can be used to inform behavior. Using more communication resources may also provide information triangulation ( Greyson, 2018 ), which can provide an individual more confidence that the information received is accurate and trustworthy.…”

Money or Melancholia? Dropout and Retention Rates in the K-pop Industry

“…This information might convey something substantial about for example emotional stability or neuroticism and if such were linked to a dropout. Whereas these media sources are more or less reliable it is still possible to obtain meaningful information if several sources provide uniform and consistent information about a basic topic (Greyson, 2018).…”

How do parents of children with ASD use information grounds to seek for ASD‐related information?

“…They generally distrust information published by stakeholders like the government, or provided by people who have no experience on child care (Walker, ). Parents often triangulate information from different sources to assess and strengthen conclusions by reducing the biases of a single approach (Greyson, ). Meanwhile, parents are highly sensitive to negative information.…”