Inquiry-Based Learning and Conceptual Change in Balance Beam Understanding

Abstract

Inquiry-based learning has the potential to foster conceptual change, but whether it can induce an advancement in strategy use is not yet known. Such an advancement seems plausible, because conceptual change can be reflected in the use of new strategies. Whether inquiry-based learning leads to advancement in strategy use can be tested with strategy-based tests, such as the balance beam test. Distinct strategies have been proposed and identified for this test. Therefore, the present study compared response patterns on the balance beam test before and after an inquiry-based lesson. The experimental condition completed a digital inquiry-based lesson about the balance beam (n = 113), and the control condition completed a similar inquiry-based lesson but investigated a different topic (n = 44). The participants were aged 8-13 years old and were unfamiliar with the law of moments. The balance beam test (pretest and posttest) consisted of 25 items. Overall accuracy in solving balance beam problems improved after the inquiry-based lesson in the balance beam (BB) condition but not in the control condition. Classes, identified with latent transition analysis (LTA), appeared to be globally in line with previously identified strategies in the balance beam test. Condition was entered as a covariate in the LTA to identify which changes in strategy use could be attributed to the experimental intervention. First, changes from pretest to posttest were found, which supported that a change in strategy use occurred in some children. Second, there were more improvements in the BB condition, and these improvements indicated larger gains compared to the control condition. This means that in science education, it is important to map out prior knowledge and its effect on learning paths. Overall, results suggested that conceptual change could be measured as a change in strategy use and modeled with LTA to reveal that 26% of the children showed conceptual change after a single inquiry-based lesson.

How is students’ mental model in the post-pandemic era? Work and Energy Concept Analysis using the Wright Map

“…Based on the results obtained, physics learning can be carried out both offline, online, or blended, so that it can be designed to support conceptual change so as to support the formation of mental models. As with previous research, presenting active, factual learning and activities that can compare prior knowledge with scientific conceptions can support the formation of a more optimal mental model (Hermita, 2017;Jiang et al, 2018;Syuhendri, 2017;Graaf, 2020).…”

“…Learning is an activity to form students' mental models (Graaf, 2020;Eshach et al, 2018). Therefore, the achievement of studends' mental model is influenced by the learning carried out.…”

Comparing Guidance via Implicit and Explicit Model Progressions in a Collaborative Inquiry-Based Learning Environment with Different-Aged Learners

“…The often-used Balance Scale Task (BST) [40] was used to study the content knowledge of balance. The BST's internal consistency has been reported as good with a large sample of different-aged learners (Cronbach's α = 0.80), and it is usable even with learners as young as five years old [40] and has also been used with similar age groups as in this study [41]. The BST consists of five blocks of five items each.…”

Temporal Aspects of Learning Analytics - Grounding Analyses in Concepts of Time

“…In other studies, the division of cases is based on similarities in the developmental sequences. For example van der Graaf [49] used latent transition analysis to classify children solving a balance beam problem into 5 different profiles based on the ordering of the strategies they used. Non-recurrent sequences can be analyzed in between subject designs as illustrated above, but also within-subject designs.…”