“…Further, by the authors' own admission (Kumar et al, 2023), the four sites (CHPU, SOLN, SANR, SHLS) closest to the KTF-1 segment are malfunctioning and therefore the authors decided not to use the unreliable data from these sites in subsequent analysis. In fact, one of the GNSS sites CHPU is located within a strongly deforming piedmont zone (Kim et al, 2023;Sahadevan and Pandey, 2023). Therefore, in view of the quality of the datasets and site conditions, it is felt that Kumar et al (2023) could provide no clarity on the sense of movement, and ambiguity about the nature of slip/offset on the KTF-1 remains, both in the long-term and short-term.…”