INSCRIBING SUBJECTS TO CITIZENSHIP: Petitions, Literacy Activism, and the Performativity of Signature in Rural Tamil India

Abstract

This essay examines how activists in rural southern India have sought to reshape the field of political communication by encouraging lower‐caste women to submit written, signed petitions to district‐level government offices, and so represent themselves to the state. I argue that contradictions between democratic recognition and the will to development that inhere to the political structure of contemporary governance in rural India correspond to tensions within the semiotic structure of signature itself, between constative representation and performative creation. Governmentality and the forms of communication that it requires often rest on the notion that written self‐representation constitutes an act of political agency. But the limits of a governmental communicative reason that would conflate written subject and agent become especially clear in postcolonial contexts where the construction of those citizens that would be represented is in fact a product of the very act of representation. It is the narrative of development‐as‐pedagogy that holds out the promise of a future alignment of communicative frameworks, technologies, and participant roles, allowing for the transparent self‐representation of an already‐constituted citizen. By tracking the ambivalent experience of one group of women in particular, this account focuses on how the logic of signature as self‐representation has served to recontextualize the marginality of petitioners as something within the state's broader field of power.

Introduction to the Special Issue, Commitment to Alterity and Its Disavowal: The Politics of Display of Belonging

“…The other is cultural citizenship, which is achieved through referring back to the immigrants' home country and making them Cultural Others to the Italian mainstream. These are two different ways to become an Italian citizen (also see Cody 2009). In analysing transnational Chinese and their adaptable notion of citizenship and sovereignty in accumulating capital, Ong uses the notion of 'flexible citizenship' which refers to 'the cultural logics of capitalist accumulation, travel, and displacement that induce subjects to respond fluidly and opportunistically to changing political-economic conditions' (Ong 1999: 6).…”

Best Practices for Besting the Bureaucracy: Avoiding Military Service in Israel

“…In his investigations into everyday corruption in northern India, Akhil Gupta () notes that high performative competence is required to make one's way through the grey zones of bureaucratic interaction. Training in literacy (Cody ), bureaucratic narrativization, and legal and rights consciousness (Goodale and Merry ; Merry ) are central themes of this literature. Such efforts serve to make persons more legible to the state (Scott ).…”

Movement Actors in the Education Bureaucracy: The Figured World of Activity Based Learning in Tamil Nadu

“…Before long, founders of TNSF organized another grassroots voluntary movement, Arivoli Iyakkam, “a social movement to spread literacy and Enlightenment rationality” (Cody :351). Soon, however, Arivoli Iyakkam was “taken up as a joint NGO‐state program under the National Literacy Mission,” becoming a voluntary movement adopted, funded, and backed by the state (Cody :351) . The National Literacy Mission (NLM) was organized in 1988 with the objective of promoting full functional literacy for the adult population in India.…”