Inscriptions of resilience: Bond ratings and the government of climate risk in Greater Miami, Florida

Abstract

In recent years, credit rating agencies have begun to incorporate a municipality's resilience and vulnerability to climate change into their US municipal bond rating methods. Drawing on the case of Greater Miami resilience planning and Science and Technology Studies-inspired work on inscriptive devices, I investigate how this incorporation practically happens, and how it shapes the ways that Greater Miami governments attempt to govern climate risk through resilience investments. What “counts” as resilience there, I suggest, is increasingly an effect of the observational practices of rating agencies. However, the still-emergent status of resilience as an object of knowledge among rating agencies and Greater Miami governments means that resilience retains a degree of plasticity, allowing government officials and residents alike to mobilize the term for different purposes and toward different ends. In tracing the emergent relations between rating agency practice on climate risk and local government resilience investments, the paper makes two contributions to scholarship in economic and urban geography. First, it illuminates the ways that extra-local practices of expert valuation shape the local construction of environmental fixes. Second, it offers insights into how one of the key actors of the 2007–2008 financial crisis is beginning to lay the epistemic groundwork for future economic crises and inequalities in and between cities, this time as they relate to climate change impacts and a city's supposed resilience and vulnerability to them.

Development of New Products for Climate Change Resilience in South Africa—The Catastrophe Resilience Bond Introduction

“…Global organisations such as the United Nations and World Bank as well as several researchers have pushed for the advancement of climate change resilience research and investments (Więckowska 2013;Vaijhala and Rhodes 2018;Cox 2021;Ando et al 2022;World Bank 2022;UNDRR 2023). Furthermore, the UN has adopted a net-zero carbon-free world goal by 2050 (CoP 27 and CoP 28) as a way of combatting the effects of climate change, which are believed to have triggered some devastating catastrophe events such as cyclones, hurricanes, earthquakes, tornados, floods, droughts, etc.…”

“…Thus, a CAT R Bond is a special type of catastrophe bond for a specific catastrophe or climate change risk, for example, a flood (Cox 2021). Dhanjal (2020) posits that CAT R Bonds provide unique opportunities:…”

Fiduciary Activism From Below: Green Gentrification, Pension Finance, and the Possibility of Just Urban Futures

“…This occurs through the geographical expansion of financial markets and instruments to new cities and regions (Bigger & Webber, 2021). Through these processes, local governments have come to depend increasingly on the capital and the technical expertise supplied by insurance companies, bond markets and investors to imagine and implement climate resilience strategies (Collier & Cox, 2021;Cox, 2022;Hilbrandt & Grubbauer, 2020;Taylor & Weinkle, 2020).…”

ANTI‐PUBLIC FINANCE? The Democratic Effects of Municipal Bond Markets

“…Scholars have argued that these ratings have since come to control the allocation of capital under financialized capitalism (Feher, 2021)—they assign financial value to states (Lemoine, 2014) and determine the fiscal management of local governments (Hackworth, 2002). Yet such arguments often assume ‘that the rating's disciplinary power on a given issue is formed and is awaiting “transmission” to a government that can always be disciplined in a predictable way’ (Cox, 2022: 5). Indeed, framing the power of credit ratings as disciplinary obscures one of the key features which make such ratings effective: they are a style of public address—an opinion about creditworthiness meant to influence other opinions—which may be openly debated in a diversity of forums and styles and, as a result, may change.…”