Inside the Physician's Black Bag: Critical Ingredients of Brief Alcohol Interventions

Abstract

Brief primary care interventions structured around patient workbooks have been shown to be effective in modifying hazardous drinking behavior. However, the critical ingredients of such interventions are not well understood, possibly contributing to their under-utilization. Seventeen campus-based clinicians trained in a brief, workbook-based alcohol intervention participated in a qualitative study to identify the most promising clinician-patient interaction components within this shared approach, utilizing a focus group with the clinicians and ranking of the 24 workbook ingredients. Based on the clinicians' collective experience, consensus emerged around the perceived strength of five main components: (1) providing a summary of the patient's drinking level, (2) discussing drinking likes and dislikes, (3) discussing life goals, (4) encouraging a riskreduction agreement, and (5) asking patients to track their drinking (on cards provided for this purpose). This is the first paper to examine primary care physician perspectives on potentially critical components of effective brief alcohol intervention. (150 words)

Combining Rapid HIV Testing and a Brief Alcohol Intervention in Young Unhealthy Drinkers in the Emergency Department: A Pilot Study

“…These components appear to be important aspects of interventions effective at reducing alcohol-related problems among college students (18), who were well represented in our study. In addition, our intervention culminated in a risk-reduction agreement, a potentially critical component of effective interventions (19). Previous evaluations of the impact of brief interventions in the ED have been mixed (20).…”

Facilitators and barriers to initiating change in medical intensive care unit survivors with alcohol use disorders: A qualitative study

“…Brief interventions are 5 to 30 minute sessions spent with a patient addressing their alcohol consumption, identifying goals, and assembling a plan to reduce alcohol-related harm [1, 12]. Such interventions are frequently delivered to patients who are not specifically seeking help for their drinking [13].…”

Examining the Impact of Separate Components of a Multicomponent Intervention Designed to Reduce At‐Risk Drinking Among Older Adults: The Project SHARE Study

“…Studies of alcohol risk reduction have largely focused on describing the success of multicomponent interventions, with less attention paid to the specific components within the intervention that may be most important. A recent study asked 17 primary care physicians who frequently deliver alcohol reduction interventions for young adults to rate the most effective approaches they include (Grossberg et al, 2010). Of 24 possible intervention components, 5 were identified as the most useful, specifically summarizing the patient's drinking level, making a drinking agreement, keeping a drinking diary, discussing drinking likes and dislikes, and discussing life goals.…”