Arylidene-Δ 2 -pyrrolin-4-ones undergo organocatalyzed annulation with malononitrile, furnishing dihydropyrano[3,2-b]pyrroles (18 examples, 0-77% ee in dichloromethane, 11-44% ee in methanol). The products could be enantiomerically enriched by trituration (11 examples, 95-99% ee). Enantioselectivity was dependent on the nature of the substrate and the conformation of the catalyst, which in turn was solventcontrolled. The reaction mechanism, which included two pseudo-enantiomeric organocatalyst conformations, was investigated by experimental and quantum chemical methods. The reaction mechanism consists of Michael addition reaction step followed by 6-exo-dig annulation, which was found to be the rate determining step. Additionally, it was identified that the preferred reaction pathway follows the model originally proposed by Pápai et al.