Institutionalizing problem‐oriented policing: An evaluation of the EMUN reform in Israel

Abstract

The authors would like to thank the Planning and Organization Division of the Israel Police, in particular Lilach Laufman-Gavri for her leadership, and the staff members of the Research, Measurement & Evaluation and GIS subunits for their ongoing support and input that enabled this research. We also thank the commanders and officers interviewed as part of the study for their time and effort. We would like to acknowledge Liz Groff and David Wilson for their methodology consultations and advice. We are also grateful to the special issue editors, Stephen Mastrofski, and the anonymous reviewers for their insightful feedback on earlier versions of this article. Funding information Ministry of Public Security Israel Research Summary: In 1979 Herman Goldstein proposed a radical reform-problem-oriented policing (POP)-which has had tremendous impact on scholars and practitioners. Even though his paper and subsequent work led to a large body of literature on how to carry out problem-oriented policing tactics, scholars have often ignored the question of how POP can be institutionalized in police agencies. In this article, we evaluate a reform in Israel-EMUN-that attempted to institutionalize problem-oriented policing on a national scale. Focusing on property crime, we compare three treatment stations (with high, moderate, and low crime) with control stations chosen through a systematic matching procedure. We find that there are large and significant reductions in the targeted areas (termed "polygons") for high-and moderate-property-crime stations as compared with the control stations. We also do not find evidence of displacement but instead evidence of significant diffusions of crime control benefits. Importantly, property crime declines occurred in these stations overall. Significant benefits were not found for the lowcrime treatment station. We attribute this to the low base rate of crimes and low resource allocation in this station. Policy Implications: These findings suggest that the EMUN reform provides a potential model for institutionalizing problem-oriented policing as an organizational reform. EMUN attempted to support and reinforce each of the main steps of the problem-oriented

Illuminating the Concept of Community (Group)-Level Procedural Justice: A Qualitative Analysis of Protestors’ Group-Level Experiences With the Police

“…With regard to Israel as the study location: over the past few decades, Israel has come to be recognized as a useful setting for the study of policing, because it is similar in important ways to many policing contexts in the West, but, as reviewed by Jonathan-Zamir et al (2015), the Israel Police has also had to face unique circumstances and challenges. Further elaboration on the Israel Police (Israel's national police agency), its history, structure, and functions, as well as the ways in which Israeli policing resembles and differs from other policing contexts, can be found elsewhere (Jonathan-Zamir et al, 2015Jonathan-Zamir & Harpaz, 2018;Weisburd et al, 2009Weisburd et al, , 2020. What is important to note here is that the model used by the Israel Police to handle protest events is similar in its main goals, procedures and restraints to those used by other police agencies in the Western, democratic world.…”

The long-term effects of policing the COVID-19 pandemic: Public attitudes toward the police in the ‘new normal’

“… 4 More generally, we should note that the IP shows much resemblance to many police agencies in the West in terms of its core functions and restraints, and indeed Israel has become an important location for policing research in recent decades (e.g., Abu et al ., 2017 ; Hasisi et al ., 2009 ; Jonathan-Zamir and Harpaz, 2018 ; Perry and Jonathan-Zamir, 2014 ; Perry et al ., 2017 ; Weisburd et al ., 2020 ). Further information on the characteristics of the IP as an organization and the nature of policing in Israel can be found elsewhere (e.g.…”

Testing the Effects of a Problem-Solving Policing Strategy on Crime Outcomes: The Promise of an Integrated Approach

“…The process calls for response assessment to gauge impact, which then informs future problem-solving. The evidence that problem-solving can impact myriad crime and disorder in and around crime hot spots, is promising as studies reveal that problem-solving can impact fear of crime (Cordner, 1986), violence in hot spots (Braga, et al, 1999), disorder in parks (Baker & Wolfer, 2003), and property crime (Weisburd et al, 2020). Armed with this evidence, practitioners report adopting problem-solving as an on-the-ground policing tool (Reaves, 2015).…”

“…Scholars and practitioners have spent the last several decades testing and evaluating the use of SARA, and studies show that problem-solving can positively impact different types of challenges in and outside of crime hot spot areas (Braga et al, 1999; Weisburd et al, 2010). More intently, researchers and practitioners have come to understand how tailored problem-solving strategies are applied to diverse problems in a variety of community safety contexts (Baker & Wolfer, 2003; Braga & Bond, 2008; Braga et al, 1999; Groff et al, 2015; Koper et al, 2013; Mazzerole, et al, 2000; Weisburd et al, 2020). As this evidence grows, the adoption of problem-solving as reported by police has also increased (Reaves, 2015).…”

“…Others (Cordner, 1998) have found that some police practitioners do not see a problem-oriented approach constituting the real work of the police. Arguably, these macro-level dimensions of problem-solving remain underexplored (Bond & Nader, 2018; Lum & Koper, 2017; Weisburd et al, 2020).…”