During the management of patients in acute trauma the resulting transient hyperglycemia is treated by administration of insulin. Since the effect of insulin, a quorum sensing compound, together with glucose affects biofilm formation in a concentration-specific manner, we hypothesize that the insulin/glucose ratio over the physiologic range modulates biofilm formation potentially influencing the establishment of infection through biofilm formation. Methods: A variety of Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria were grown in peptone (1%) yeast nitrogen base broth overnight in 96-well plates with various concentrations of glucose and insulin. Biofilm formation was determined by the crystal violet staining procedure. Expression of insulin binding was determined by fluorescent microscopy (FITC-insulin). Controls were buffer alone, insulin alone, and glucose alone. Results: Overall, maximal biofilm levels were measured at 220 mg/dL of glucose, regardless of insulin concentration (10, 100, 200 µU/mL) of the organism tested. In general, insulin with glucose over the range of 160–180 mg/dL exhibited a pattern of biofilm suppression. However, either above or below this range, the presence of insulin in combination with glucose significantly modulated (increase or decrease) biofilm formation in a microbe-specific pattern. This modulation appears for some organisms to be reflective of the glucose-regulated intrinsic expression of bacterial insulin receptor expression. Conclusion: Insulin at physiologic levels (normal and hyperinsulinemic) in combination with glucose can affect biofilm formation in a concentration-specific and microbe-specific manner. These findings may provide insight into the importance of co-regulation of the insulin/glucose ratio in patient management.