TX 75083-3836 U.S.A., fax 01-972-952-9435.
AbstractScoping studies using data from three mature fields suggest that simple workflows that use only essential stratigraphic and facies constraints are as good in capturing overall reservoir fluid flow response as complex, highly constrained workflows that use detailed stratigraphic and facies constraints. Thus, considerable time and cost saving may be realized during initial model building and updating if simple, but appropriate, workflows are used.The reservoirs studied include a Permian-age carbonate reservoir in New Mexico, an Upper Miocene deepwater clastic reservoir in California, and an Eocene-age shallow water clastic reservoir in Venezuela. Two dimensional cross section models of the deepwater clastic reservoir showed that cumulative production and water breakthrough times were essentially the same for models using the two major stratigraphic picks as for models constrained by 12 detailed stratigraphic picks. Three dimensional streamline simulation was used to demonstrate that adding facies and rock type constraints had little impact on recovery factors for a carbonate reservoir scoping project area consisting of 25, 5spot waterflood patterns. Likewise, a very complex workflow for the shallow water clastic data set from Venezuela constrained by eight facies and 16 detailed stratigraphic picks yielded the same reservoir response as a simple, two facies, and four major stratigraphic picks constrained workflow. These studies suggest that for reservoirs with moderate to high net to gross (>30-40%) or with small differences in the porosity vs. permeability trends of facies/rock types that simple geological modeling workflows are adequate for subsequent fluid flow simulation. Models generated using the shallow water clastic data sets and evaluated using three dimensional streamline simulation showed that varying the semivariogram range parameters by factors between 0.25 and 2 times the data driven range value also had little effect on reservoir response.An important issue surrounds the impact of up-scaling on fluid flow response. Vertical up-scaling by factors commonly used for full field simulation models has little impact on fluid flow response based on studies of the New Mexico carbonate reservoir and the shallow water clastic reservoir in Venezuela. However, areal up-scaling of models generated using a very fine 50 foot areal grid significantly alters the fluid flow characteristics and warrants additional study.