Integrating Dynamic Material Flow Analysis and Computable General Equilibrium Models for Both Mass and Monetary Balances in Prospective Modeling: A Case for the Chinese Building Sector

Abstract

Integrated Assessment Models based on Computable General Equilibrium (IAM/CGE) and dynamic Material Flow Analysis (dynamic MFA) are two most widely used prospective model families to assess large-scale and long-term socioeconomic metabolism (SEM) and inform sustainable SEM transition. The latter approach could complement the former by a more explicit understanding of service provision, in-use stocks, and material cycles in a mass balanced framework. In this paper, we demonstrated this by integrating the dynamic MFA and CGE model approaches for the Chinese building sector from 2012 to 2030. Our results revealed the impacts of building stock dynamics on sectoral and economy-wide CO 2 emissions: lower service saturation levels and later saturation time of building stock development could free up investment on buildings and accumulatively save up to 25.4 Gt in embodied CO 2 emissions of the building construction sector, representing a 2.7-fold of 2012 countrywide CO 2 emissions. However, the save-ups are partly compensated by an increase of embodied CO 2 emissions in the other sectors due to economy-wide rebound effect (ca. 18.8 Gt or about 74%). The integrated model we developed could help ensure both mass and monetary balances, explore rebound effects in prospective modelling, and thus better understand the economy-wide consequences of infrastructure development.

The use of steel in the United Kingdom's transport sector: A stock–flow–service nexus case study

“…In 2001, prices were 20% lower compared to 1991 (at constant prices). A decrease in real prices from 1991 to 2009 was also observed (Cambridge Econometrics, 2015). During the same period, petrol prices rose but this was compensated by increases in bus and rail fares (Dargay & Hanly, 2007).…”

Material efficiency strategies to reducing greenhouse gas emissions associated with buildings, vehicles, and electronics—a review

“…Where ME reduces costs, such as with light-weighted or shared vehicles, the question is whether it will result in an increased demand. Both modeling and empirical evidence point to a sizable rebound effect to energy efficiency [209] and a similar effect applies to materials [210,211]. We have highlighted some fundamental behavioral questions, such as whether ATs will be used to complement public transportation (last mile) or whether they will multiply the trips taken and reduce urban densities.…”

Documentation of part IV of the RECC model framework: Open Dynamic Material Systems Model for the Resource Efficiency-Climate Change Nexus (ODYM-RECC), v2.2

“…Finally, there are some recent attempts to link material consumption to economy-wide models more directly. First, by converting sectoral output of CGE models into material flows by applying product material composition and prices (Cao et al, 2018;Winning et al, 2017), and second, by converting end-user demand for new products provided by energy system models into material flows by applying product material composition data (Deetman et al, 2018;Watari et al, 2019). These attempts are a step in the right direction, but the CGE approaches focus on single economic sectors only and do not consider material cycles and the mitigation potentials therein, and the energy system-based approaches only estimate final demand and currently do not consider the material cycle response.…”