Integration of science and monitoring of river ecosystem health to guide investments in catchment protection and rehabilitation

Abstract

SUMMARY1. Stream ecosystem health monitoring and reporting need to be developed in the context of an adaptive process that is clearly linked to identified values and objectives, is informed by rigorous science, guides management actions and is responsive to changing perceptions and values of stakeholders. To be effective, monitoring programmes also need to be underpinned by an understanding of the probable causal factors that influence the condition or health of important environmental assets and values. This is often difficult in stream and river ecosystems where multiple stressors, acting at different spatial and temporal scales, interact to affect water quality, biodiversity and ecosystem processes. 2. In this article, we describe the development of a freshwater monitoring programme in South East Queensland, Australia, and how this has been used to report on ecosystem health at a regional scale and to guide investments in catchment protection and rehabilitation. We also discuss some of the emerging science needs to identify the appropriate scale and spatial arrangement of rehabilitation to maximise river ecosystem health outcomes and, at the same time, derive other benefits downstream.3. An objective process was used to identify potential indicators of stream ecosystem health and then test these across a known catchment land-use disturbance gradient. From the 75 indicators initially tested, 22 from five indicator groups (water quality, ecosystem metabolism, nutrient cycling, invertebrates and fish) responded strongly to the disturbance gradient, and 16 were subsequently recommended for inclusion in the monitoring programme. The freshwater monitoring programme was implemented in 2002, funded by local and State government authorities, and currently involves the assessment of over 120 sites, twice per year. This information, together with data from a similar programme on the region's estuarine and coastal marine waters, forms the basis of an annual report card that is presented in a public ceremony to local politicians and the broader community. 4. Several key lessons from the SEQ Healthy Waterways Programme are likely to be transferable to other regional programmes aimed at improving aquatic ecosystem health, including the importance of a shared common vision, the involvement of committed individuals, a cooperative approach, the need for defensible science and effective communication. 5. Thematic implications: this study highlights the use of conceptual models and objective testing of potential indicators against a known disturbance gradient to develop a freshwater ecosystem health monitoring programme that can diagnose the probable causes of degradation from multiple stressors and identify the appropriate spatial scale for rehabilitation or protection. This approach can lead to more targeted management investments in catchment protection and rehabilitation, greater public confidence that limited funds are being well spent and better outcomes for stream and river ecosystem health.

Within-River Phosphorus Retention: Accounting for a Missing Piece in the Watershed Phosphorus Puzzle

“…The upper part of the IRW drains an area of northwest Arkansas which is one of the fastest growing metropolitan areas of the U.S. Agriculture in the IRW is dominated by poultry and beef cattle production. The portion of northwest Arkansas, in which the IRW is located, is the top producing area for beef cattle in Arkansas and second in the USA for poultry production behind Georgia 38,39 . There were 1.04 billion birds reared in 2011 in about 1600 active poultry houses in the IRW 38,40 , with about 30% of the poultry litter generally applied to pastureland in the IRW and the remainder exported out of the watershed 41,42 .…”

“…The portion of northwest Arkansas, in which the IRW is located, is the top producing area for beef cattle in Arkansas and second in the USA for poultry production behind Georgia 38,39 . There were 1.04 billion birds reared in 2011 in about 1600 active poultry houses in the IRW 38,40 , with about 30% of the poultry litter generally applied to pastureland in the IRW and the remainder exported out of the watershed 41,42 . The Illinois River is impounded by the Lake Tenkiller dam and Lake Tenkiller has been subject to nuisance algal blooms since the 1970s 40 .…”

A new framework to evaluate ecosystem health: a case study in the Wei River basin, China

“…It can reflect the human disturbance directly but is affected by the person who assesses the condition. Assessment of the relative performance of the various indicators groups can be used to interpret probable causal processes (Bunn et al 2010), knowing that some indicators (e.g., water quality) respond more closely to riparian zone, while others appear to respond to land use activities at the broader catchment scale (e.g., fish). Key processes link the five groups at various scales (Davies et al 2010).…”

“…is a fundamental and increasingly important water management issue around the world, especially in Australia (Davies et al 2010;Bunn et al 2010), USA (Barbour et al 1999), and Europe (Hering et al 2010). There are two controversial concepts about ecosystem health recently.…”

Purposeful collective action in ambiguous and contested situations: exploring ‘enabling capacities’ and cross-level interplay

“…It is one of the fastest growing regions in the country, with a population of 2.8 million in 2006 forecast to expand to 4.6 million by 2031 (DIP 2009). Waterway health is recognised as a major sustainability challenge (SEQHWP 2006;Bunn et al 2010). The region's many fresh and estuarine waterways flow into the highly ecologically-significant marine receiving water body of Moreton Bay (SEQHWP 2006), which is marine park and recognised in international agreements such as Ramsar.…”