“…As IRS CSI acquisition (especially the CSI of eavesdroppers) may not be accurate in practice, it is necessary to design the robust IRS passive beamforming in IRS-aided PHY systems under the statistical (cascaded) CSI error model (see, e.g., [112], [119], [123], [132]). Besides, the authors in [233] employed the IRS to deliberately introduce extra randomness in the wireless propagation environment for hiding active wireless transmissions, and revealed the trade-off between the secrecy performance and CSI accuracy. Nevertheless, several practical issues in IRS-aided PHY systems have not been well tackled, e.g., the optimal design for detecting eavesdroppers, the trade-off between channel estimation and achievable secrecy performance, which deserve future studies.…”