Summary:The majority of poor-risk lymphoma patients are not cured with conventional chemotherapy. There is evidence for the superiority of single high-dose chemotherapy in such patients, but many still die from recurrent disease. Strategies to improve survival in these poor-risk patients include dose-intensification with high-dose chemotherapy and PBPC support, tandem autologous HDC with PBPC support, and autologous followed by non-myeloablative allogeneic transplantation. These more aggressive strategies are feasible and tolerable. Whether tandem transplantation will prove more effective than current single high-dose therapy in appropriately selected patients remains to be determined. Bone Marrow Transplantation (2001) 28, 529-535. Keywords: tandem transplantation; lymphoma; autologous; allogeneicThe majority of patients with lymphoma achieve remission with standard therapy. A small percentage of patients are refractory to initial therapy, and approximately one-third of patients with stage III-IV disease will relapse after achieving a complete response. Treatment of minimally responsive or refractory lymphoma patients remains a challenge.
Single transplantation and the poor prognosis patientProspective randomized trials show single HDC with autologous transplantation to be superior to standard-dose chemotherapy for relapsed and resistant Hodgkin's disease, 1 for consolidative therapy of poor-risk B cell NHL in first remission 2 and for relapsed chemo-sensitive intermediate or high-grade NHL. 3 An update of the PARMA study reports an 8-year EFS of 36% and OS of 47% for these latter patients. 4 Fewer than 5% of patients with poor-risk NHL or HD who have induction failure and receive conventional salvage chemotherapy are alive at 5 years. NHL patients with induction failure who undergo HDC and autotransplantation have an overall survival at 5 years of 37%. 5 Data from the ABMTR show HD patients with induction Correspondence: DR CS Hesdorffer, Division of Medical Oncology, MHB 6N 435, 177 Ft. Washington Avenue, New York, NY 10032, USA failure who subsequently undergo HDC have progressionfree and overall survivals at 3 years of 38% and 50%, respectively. 6 Data by Sweetenham et al 7 from the EBMT are similar, reporting an actuarial 5-year OS rate of 36% and PFS rate of 32%.Allogeneic transplantation alone does not appear to offer a survival advantage over autologous transplant for lymphoma. 8,9 Studies suggest a graft-versus-lymphoma effect, but this has not translated into increased survival due to the high treatment-related mortality associated with allogeneic transplantation. Further prospective trials, randomized on the basis of HLA-identical donor availability, may provide more reliable data on this issue. 10 While salvage rates of 45-60% are achieved with HDC in patients with relapsed NHL and HD with good prognostic factors, adverse prognostic factors, such as relapse within 1 year of initial treatment, stage III/IV relapse or chemoresistance, portend a poorer outcome, with likely cure in less than 40%. The IP...