Suprastructures of the extracellular matrix, such as banded collagen fibrils, microfibrils, filaments, or networks, are composites comprising more than one type of macromolecule. The suprastructural diversity reflects tissue-specific requirements and is achieved by formation of macromolecular composites that often share their main molecular components alloyed with minor components. Both, the mechanisms of formation and the final macromolecular organizations depend on the identity of the components and their quantitative contribution. Collagen I is the predominant matrix constituent in many tissues and aggregates with other collagens and/or fibril-associated macromolecules into distinct types of banded fibrils. Here, we studied co-assembly of collagens I and XI, which co-exist in fibrils of several normal and pathologically altered tissues, including fibrous cartilage and bone, or osteoarthritic joints. Immediately upon initiation of fibrillogenesis, the proteins co-assembled into alloy-like stubby aggregates that represented efficient nucleation sites for the formation of composite fibrils. Propagation of fibrillogenesis occurred by exclusive accretion of collagen I to yield composite fibrils of highly variable diameters. Therefore, collagen I/XI fibrils strikingly differed from the homogeneous fibrillar alloy generated by collagens II and XI, although the constituent polypeptides of collagens I and II are highly homologous. Thus, the mode of aggregation of collagens into vastly diverse fibrillar composites is finely tuned by subtle differences in molecular structures through formation of macromolecular alloys.Extracellular matrix aggregates, despite their functional and morphological diversity, often contain the same type of macromolecules as their major constituent. In tendons, for example, large and strongly banded fibrils of variable width are aggregated into bundles that resist extreme tensile forces in one dimension. By contrast, thin fibrils with uniform diameter and spacing are organized into orthogonal sheets forming the translucent corneal stromal matrix that withstands high traction in two dimensions. However, the same protein, i.e. collagen I, is the quantitatively predominant component in both suprastructures (1, 2). The major cartilage collagen is type II, but this protein, too, is common to fibrils with different structures and functions (3, 4). Finally, collagens I and II occur together in fibrocartilage (5), a tissue characterized by a high resistance to both compressive and tensile forces and that contains fibrous bundles in addition to an amorphous extrafibrillar matrix rich in proteoglycans.Collagens I and II are very similar in their molecular structure. They both contain three polypeptides with a central sequence of 1014 amino acids in which strictly every third residue is glycine. In addition, these glycine residues are frequently preceded by hydroxyproline and/or followed by proline. The (Gly-Xaa-Yaa) n sequences are flanked at both ends by short non-periodic sequences, called telopeptide...