Supported ReO x /Al 2 O 3 catalysts were investigated for propylene metathesis as a function of surface rhenia loading and extensively characterized with in situ UV−vis, Raman, IR, XANES/EXAFS, and isotopic 18 O− 16 O exchange studies. The experimental studies were complemented with DFT calculations using realistic models of the alumina surface. The surface ReO x sites were found to be isolated surface dioxo (O) 2 ReO 2 species, which represent the most stable surface rhenia structures on alumina as shown by DFT. Two distinct surface ReO 4 species, however, were found to be present and only slightly differ in their bridging Re−O−Al bond lengths brought about by anchoring at different sites of the Al 2 O 3 support. The deformed surface ReO 4 −I species preferentially anchor at more basic μ 1 Al IV and μ 1 Al VI sites and are difficult to activate for propylene metathesis. The surface ReO 4 −II species are formed at more acidic μ 2 Al VI and μ 3 Al VI sites and are the catalytic active sites for propylene metathesis. The surface ReO 4 −II sites were readily activated by propylene while the deformed surface ReO 4 −I sites were almost not affected by propylene, with only a few sites being activated. The steady-state propylene metathesis reaction rates are much higher for the surface ReO 4 −II sites than the deformed surface ReO 4 −I sites. The formation of the less reactive deformed surface ReO 4 −I species could be blocked by occupation of the μ 1 Al IV sites with sacrificial surface TaO x species that resulted in catalysts exclusively containing the more active surface ReO 4 −II sites on alumina. This is the f irst study to demonstrate that the surface ReO 4 −II sites are the precursors for the catalytic active sites for propylene metathesis by supported ReO 4 /Al 2 O 3 catalysts and to molecularly design olefin metathesis catalysts that exclusively contain isolated surface ReO 4 −II sites.