The
critical adsorption points (CAP) for ring and linear polymers
are determined and compared using Monte Carlo simulations and liquid
chromatography experiments. The CAP is defined as the coelution point
of ring or linear polymers with different molecular weights (MW).
Computational studies show that the temperature at the CAP, T
CAP, for rings is higher than T
CAP for linear polymers regardless of whether the chains
are modeled as random walks or self-avoiding walks. The difference
in the CAP can be attributed only to the architectural difference.
Experimentally, four pairs of linear and ring polystyrenes (PS) of
different MW were synthesized and purified. Care was taken to account
for the difference between the end-groups in linear polymers and the
linkage unit in ring polymers. Elution of these polymers using a C18
bonded silica stationary phase and a CH2Cl2/CH3CN mixed eluent were studied. The temperature at the coelution
point, T
CAP, and the coelution time at
the CAP, t
E,CAP, were determined for both
ring and linear polymers. Experimentally, it was found that T
CAP of linear PS is lower than T
CAP of cyclic PS and t
E,CAP of linear PS is shorter than t
E,CAP of
ring PS. Therefore, at the CAP of linear polymers, ring polymers elute
later in order of increasing MW while, at the CAP of ring polymers,
linear polymers elute earlier in order of decreasing MW. This is in
excellent agreement with the Monte Carlo computer simulation results.
We also found that the functionality effect can interfere in the LCCC
separation of ring polymers from their linear precursors.