Interactive Text Ranking with Bayesian Optimization: A Case Study on Community QA and Summarization

Abstract

For many NLP applications, such as question answering and summarization, the goal is to select the best solution from a large space of candidates to meet a particular user’s needs. To address the lack of user or task-specific training data, we propose an interactive text ranking approach that actively selects pairs of candidates, from which the user selects the best. Unlike previous strategies, which attempt to learn a ranking across the whole candidate space, our method uses Bayesian optimization to focus the user’s labeling effort on high quality candidates and integrate prior knowledge to cope better with small data scenarios. We apply our method to community question answering (cQA) and extractive multidocument summarization, finding that it significantly outperforms existing interactive approaches. We also show that the ranking function learned by our method is an effective reward function for reinforcement learning, which improves the state of the art for interactive summarization.

The Impact of Expertise in the Loop for Exploring Machine Rationality

“…To cover a spectrum of different application domains, we consider text summarization [64], photo color enhancement [39][40][41], and a 3D model simplification task [21,31,53] to evaluate the relation between user expertise, satisfaction, and system outcome quality when interacting with an intelligent system. Figure 1 shows one of our ranking interfaces for HITL optimization.…”